Meme Categories:
Category: Medicine
First Seen:
2023-05-10T21:03:36+00:00
Gemma-3-27b's Take:
Okay, here's a breakdown of the meme image, addressing the requested theoretical frameworks where applicable. It's a darkly humorous image, and the analysis will reflect that. **Visual Description** The meme utilizes the blocky, Lego-like figures from the mobile game *Bitizens*. It’s a three-panel vertical image: * **Panel 1:** A yellow Bitizen character states, “My stomach hurts.” * **Panel 2:** A taller, yellow Bitizen figure labeled “19th Century Doctor” responds, “It’s probably ghosts.” * **Panel 3:** The “19th Century Doctor” presents a prescription labeled “Cocaine.” The overall aesthetic is deliberately simplistic and crude, leveraging the pixelated look of the *Bitizens* game to create a jarring effect when paired with the historical context implied. The humor lies in the absurdity of the diagnostic and treatment process, referencing a period when cocaine was sometimes legitimately used medicinally. --- **Foucauldian Genealogical Discourse Analysis** This meme lends itself heavily to a Foucauldian analysis, particularly through a genealogical lens. Foucault’s work examines how power operates through discourse – language, knowledge, and social practices. * **Power/Knowledge:** The meme highlights the historical *power/knowledge* nexus. In the 19th century, medical professionals held (and still do) power through their perceived authority regarding health and the body. The “diagnosis” of “ghosts” and the prescription of cocaine, though absurd now, represent a historical reality where medical knowledge differed vastly from today’s standards. This knowledge was not “truth” but a historically contingent way of understanding the body and illness. The doctor is an agent of that power, asserting their knowledge through the prescription. * **Discursive Formation:** The meme implicitly critiques the discursive formation surrounding health and medicine. It exposes how what is considered legitimate medical knowledge is not fixed, but constantly shifts. The “ghosts” diagnosis is a clear example of pseudo-science that was once accepted. * **Archaeology & Genealogy:** The image can be seen as an “archaeological” dig into the history of medical practices, unearthing a practice that appears strange and problematic from a contemporary perspective. It then uses a “genealogical” approach by tracing the historical development of this practice, showing how it emerged from a particular historical context and set of power relations. --- **Critical Theory** From a Critical Theory perspective (drawing on figures like Adorno and Horkheimer and their critique of the Enlightenment), the meme can be read as a commentary on the potentially *instrumental reason* within medical systems. The 19th-century doctor doesn’t seem to be concerned with *why* the stomach hurts, only with finding a 'solution' (even if illogical) and asserting their authority. * **Domination & Control:** The “prescription” of cocaine represents a form of control over the patient's body, disguised as care. It highlights the potential for medical knowledge to be used as a tool of domination. * **Critique of Progress:** The meme subtly questions the notion of linear medical progress. While we (generally) recognize the dangers of prescribing cocaine for stomach pain, the image prompts a reflection on *how* we currently define health, illness, and acceptable treatments. What contemporary medical practices might future generations view as similarly absurd or harmful? --- **Marxist Conflict Theory** While not the primary reading, Marxist analysis can find some purchase in this image. * **Class & Access to Healthcare:** In the 19th century (and to a degree even today), access to healthcare was stratified by class. The wealthy could afford doctors and treatments, even those with questionable efficacy, while the poor often had limited access. This meme implicitly acknowledges that the practices and "solutions" employed by the 19th-century doctor may have been disproportionately applied to certain social groups. The cocaine prescription could be framed as a means of controlling or pacifying a particular class of patient. * **Commodification of Health:** Even the prescription itself can be seen as a form of commodification, where the body is treated as an object to be fixed and controlled through market-driven treatments. --- **Postmodernism** A Postmodern reading of the meme focuses on the *deconstruction* of grand narratives and the *relativity of truth*. * **Rejection of Metanarratives:** The meme challenges the idea that medical knowledge is objective or universally valid. The doctor’s diagnosis and treatment represent a local, historically contingent truth, not a universal one. It destabilizes the idea of “correct” medicine. * **Irony & Pastiche:** The juxtaposition of the crude *Bitizen* graphics with the historical context creates an ironic effect. It is a *pastiche*— a playful, yet critical, borrowing from the past. The meme doesn't offer a solution or a critique but presents the absurdity as a form of commentary. --- **Queer Feminist Intersectional Analysis** This is the least directly applicable framework, but still offers some insight. * **Medical Misogyny & Control:** Historically, women's pain and experiences were often dismissed or pathologized. While the meme doesn’t specifically gender the patient, the 19th century was marked by a high degree of medical misogyny. The casual prescription of a substance that alters the body (cocaine) could be seen as a form of control over the patient’s agency. * **Intersectional Power Dynamics:** While not explicit, the meme allows for imagining how the "19th Century Doctor’s" diagnosis and treatment might have been affected by the patient’s race, class, or other social identities. Access to and quality of medical care were (and are) heavily influenced by intersectional power dynamics. **In Summary:** The meme is surprisingly rich in theoretical resonance. It’s a darkly humorous commentary on the history of medicine, the nature of power and knowledge, and the relativity of truth. It is particularly well-suited to Foucauldian and Critical Theory analysis, but also offers intriguing perspectives through Marxist, Postmodern, and even Queer Feminist lenses.
Llama-3.2-11b's Take:
This meme is a play on the idea that a person's stomach pain is somehow connected to a past life or supernatural experience. The text "My stomach hurts" is followed by "It's probably ghosts" and then "Anyways, here's your prescription" with a note that says "Cocaine". The meme is humorous because it takes a serious medical situation and turns it into a ridiculous and absurd scenario, implying that a doctor would prescribe a highly addictive and illegal substance as a treatment for a stomach problem.