memes.cjtrowbridge.com

Anti-Anti-Nutrek

First Seen:

2023-05-10T20:59:59+00:00

Gemma-3-27b's Take:

Okay, let's break down this image and its accompanying text through the lenses you've requested. It's a *highly* meme-able image, and its absurdity lends itself well to some of these analyses. **1. Visual Description** The image appears to be a screencap from *Star Trek: The Next Generation* (TNG). Two characters are visible: Deanna Troi (Marina Sirtis) and Captain Jean-Luc Picard (Patrick Stewart). Troi is standing slightly behind and to the side of Picard, looking down at him with a somewhat concerned expression. Picard, a man who often embodies stoic command, is appearing to have a moment of confusion. He is looking off to the side. The background is a standard corridor set from the *Enterprise-D*, with metallic walls and lighting. Overlaid on the image is text, presented as dialogue: Troi states, “Ok, Grandpa, let’s get you to bed!” and Picard’s dialogue is, "TNG used to be the 'new Trek' angry fans complained about!” This juxtaposition of Troi’s gentle, familial address with Picard’s meta-commentary on fan reception is the core of the image’s comedic effect and analytical potential. **2. Foucauldian Genealogical Discourse Analysis** This image lends itself surprisingly well to a Foucauldian analysis. The text and visual representation construct a *discourse* around fandom, aging, and the changing perception of *Star Trek*. * **Power/Knowledge:** The dialogue subtly shifts power dynamics. Troi, through her “Grandpa” address, assumes a position of caregiving and implicitly asserts a power relation over Picard, traditionally the ship's commander and a figure of authority. This is then used to comment on the power structures *within* the fan base, and how complaints shape the narrative around the show. * **Genealogy:** The phrase “TNG used to be the ‘new Trek’” points to a genealogy of *Star Trek* itself. It traces a lineage from the original series through TNG, acknowledging that *TNG* was once disruptive and met with resistance (as "new" things often are). The fact it's now a comfortable, well-loved classic is part of that genealogical shift. * **Discursive Formation:** The image forms a discourse surrounding how fandom treats the "new" thing over time. Initially resisted, the "new" becomes the standard, and a new "new" thing comes along to be resisted. **3. Critical Theory** Through the lens of Critical Theory, we can examine how the image exposes the underlying social structures at play in media consumption and fan communities. * **Ideology:** The image subtly comments on the conservative nature of fandom. Fans initially resist change, clinging to their established expectations of what *Star Trek* should be. The statement highlights how a show considered progressive and forward-thinking can still face resistance simply for being *new*. * **Hegemony:** The idea that *Star Trek* has an established, accepted “canon” (what it “should” be) is a manifestation of cultural hegemony. Resistance to *TNG* at the time challenged that established order. * **Alienation:** This is more subtle, but one could argue that the resistance to *TNG* stemmed from fans feeling alienated by a show that didn’t perfectly replicate the experiences they had with the original series. The expectation of similarity, rather than appreciation of difference, is a form of alienation. **4. Marxist Conflict Theory** Applying a Marxist framework to this image reveals tensions surrounding cultural capital and the ownership of narrative. * **Class & Cultural Capital:** The “angry fans” represent a group asserting ownership over the *Star Trek* narrative. They believe they have a right to dictate what constitutes “true” *Star Trek*, wielding their cultural capital (their knowledge, experience, and passion for the franchise) as a form of power. * **Conflict:** The dialogue embodies a conflict between the creators of *TNG* (the producers, writers, actors) and this segment of the fan base. The fans are essentially demanding that the show conform to their expectations, creating a class struggle over the control of cultural production. * **Commodity Fetishism:** While less direct, this could be extended to how fans treat *Star Trek* as a commodity of nostalgia, resisting anything that threatens its “original” value. **5. Postmodernism** The image is incredibly meta and self-aware, aligning perfectly with postmodern sensibilities. * **Meta-Narrative:** The dialogue is *about* the reception of the show, rather than being a part of the show’s internal narrative. It’s a commentary on the media itself. * **Irony and Parody:** The image is inherently ironic and parodic. The dignified Captain Picard, a symbol of serious space exploration, is reduced to a “Grandpa” figure and is discussing fan complaints. * **Deconstruction:** The image deconstructs the notion of “authenticity” in *Star Trek*. There is no single, “true” *Star Trek*; it’s a constantly evolving entity shaped by production, reception, and fan engagement. **6. Queer Feminist Intersectional Analysis** (This one is a bit of a stretch, but here's how it could be applied) * **Challenging Traditional Power Structures:** The image, while seemingly lighthearted, subtly subverts the traditional patriarchal structure of *Star Trek*. Troi, a female character, is taking on a position of caregiving and authority over the captain, while he is seemingly confused. * **Critique of Nostalgia:** Nostalgia can be seen as a conservative force that resists change and perpetuates traditional norms. The image critiques this nostalgia by highlighting how even beloved franchises like *Star Trek* are subject to change and criticism. It's important to note that the power of this image lies in its absurdity. It's a meme because it’s unexpected and funny, but it's also rich in potential for deeper analysis. The combination of the visual and the text creates a layered commentary on fandom, cultural production, and the evolving nature of nostalgia.

Llama-3.2-11b's Take:

This meme is a humorous image of two Star Trek: The Next Generation characters, Deanna Troi and William Riker, from the show's "The Best of Both Worlds, Part II" episode. The text "TNG used to be the 'new' Trek, now it's TNG" is overlaid on the image, implying that the show has aged and is no longer considered "new". The caption "TNG used to be the 'new' Trek, now it's TNG" is a play on words, referencing the show's original title and the current state of the franchise.