First Seen
2023-05-10T21:03:40+00:00
simple-description (llama3.2-vision_11b)
The meme is an image of a Reddit post from the r/AskScience community, where a user asks how to train a cat to do science. The user is joking about how cats are naturally inclined to do science, and are asking for tips on how to train their cat to do science experiments. The post is humorous and lighthearted, and is meant to be a playful take on the idea of cats being naturally inclined to do science.
detailed-analysis (gemma3-27b-vision)
Okay, here's an analysis of the Reddit post and comment, broken down by the requested theoretical frameworks. Note that some frameworks apply more strongly than others, and I'll indicate where connections are more tenuous.
## Visual Description
The image is a screenshot of a Reddit post on the subreddit r/NoStupidQuestions. The post is initiated by a user named "celem" and features a cartoonish question mark logo. The post asks how to attract crows and ravens to one’s yard. It states the poster and their partner are first-time homeowners with a sense of humor, and they desire an “ominous” house covered in birds. They explicitly state they want to befriend the birds without changing their diet or harming them. The post has received 1522 upvotes and 288 comments, with options to share and award.
The most prominent part of the image is a detailed comment by the user “DonnerPartyKebab.” The comment is formatted as a list, detailing methods of attracting and “befriending” crows, with a strong emphasis on establishing a reciprocal “trade relationship” with them, even suggesting rewarding them for bringing items.
## Foucauldian Genealogical Discourse Analysis
This framework is powerfully applicable. The entire exchange can be read as the construction of knowledge around crows/ravens and their "training." The poster asks for information, and DonnerPartyKebab constructs a discourse around crows as trainable, reciprocal entities.
Power/Knowledge: DonnerPartyKebab's comment isn't simply "information," it's an assertion of how* to understand and interact with crows. This understanding grants a kind of power – the ability to shape the crows' behavior. The comment normalizes the idea of a "trade relationship" with wild animals, and subtly posits the commenter as an expert in avian behavior.
* Genealogy: A genealogical tracing might look at how the idea of "training" animals (historically for labor, entertainment, or military purposes) has evolved to now encompass the idea of "befriending" wild animals for aesthetic or entertainment value. The poster's desire for an "ominous" house suggests an aestheticization of the wild, framed by cultural understandings of crows/ravens as symbols of the macabre.
* Discipline: The commenter’s detailed instructions for building platforms, maintaining schedules, and rewarding behavior demonstrate a subtle form of discipline – an attempt to impose order on the wild, to categorize and control the crows’ actions.
## Critical Theory
Several aspects of the post can be analyzed through a critical theoretical lens:
Commodification of Nature: The suggestion to "train" crows to bring gifts, and reward them for doing so, implicitly commodifies both the crows and their natural behaviors. This transforms living creatures into tools for human satisfaction, and reinforces a dominant worldview that sees nature as a resource to be exploited. The emphasis on getting* something from the crows (gifts, entertainment) highlights this dynamic.
* Subject-Object Dichotomy: The poster and commenter position themselves as the active subjects, and the crows as passive objects to be manipulated and trained. This reinforces a hierarchical relationship where human interests are prioritized over the crows’ natural autonomy.
* Domination and Control: The desire to “cover” the house in crows, and the detailed instructions on how to control their behavior, speak to a desire for control over the natural world.
## Marxist Conflict Theory
This is a weaker application, but still relevant:
* Alienation from Nature: The poster’s desire to "befriend" crows through a system of rewards and "training" can be seen as a manifestation of alienation from nature. Instead of fostering a genuine connection based on respect for the crows’ natural behaviors, the poster seeks to integrate them into a system of exchange.
* Exploitation (in a metaphorical sense): While not literal economic exploitation, there’s a metaphorical parallel in the suggestion to “reward” crows for bringing gifts. This transforms the crows’ foraging behavior into a form of labor, even if it’s simply for the sake of human entertainment.
* Ideology: The commenter’s approach perpetuates an ideology that justifies human dominance over the natural world, framing it as a natural and benevolent process.
## Postmodernism
Postmodern analysis can focus on the playful and ironic aspects of the exchange:
* Simulacra and Simulation: The desire to create an “ominous” house covered in crows is a simulation of a particular aesthetic – a constructed image that doesn’t necessarily have any grounding in reality. The crows become a signifier of “ominousness,” detached from their natural existence.
* Deconstruction of "Nature": The act of “befriending” crows through a system of rewards challenges the conventional notion of “nature” as something pristine and untouched. It suggests that “nature” is always already mediated by human intervention and constructed through cultural practices.
* Playfulness and Irony: There is a playful irony in the commenter’s detailed instructions for “training” crows. It acknowledges the absurdity of attempting to establish a reciprocal “trade relationship” with wild animals, yet simultaneously takes it seriously.
## Queer Feminist Intersectional Analysis
This is the weakest, and most strained application, but can be explored:
* Challenging Anthropocentric Norms: The commenter's proposition of a reciprocal relationship, while still inherently power-imbalanced, subtly challenges the traditional human-centric view of animal relationships. The idea of "giving back" to the crows could be seen as a disruption of the dominant narrative of humans as the sole benefactors.
* Deconstructing Domination: From a feminist perspective, the framing of the "training" as a controlled exchange could be critiqued as a micro-level enactment of power dynamics. Challenging these dynamics requires a more reciprocal and non-hierarchical relationship with non-human animals.
* Intersectional Consideration: A full intersectional analysis would require consideration of the broader social and ecological contexts that shape human-animal relationships, including issues of environmental justice, speciesism, and the historical exploitation of both animals and marginalized human groups.
I hope this detailed breakdown is helpful. It illustrates how a single Reddit post can be interpreted through multiple theoretical lenses, revealing layers of meaning and complexity.
simple-description (llama3.2-vision)
The meme is a screenshot of a Reddit post asking for advice on how to attract a large number of birds to one's yard, with a humorous tone. The post says "How do I attract a large number of birds to my yard? I want to be the bird lady" and the top comment responds with a sarcastic joke about the author wanting to be the "bird lady" and provides a humorous tip on how to attract birds to one's yard.
tesseract-ocr
PA estrella eli cy @ Pesce ae une ea ~ 1 @i 82 How do | attract a ton of crows/ ravens to my NEltekd (VT Ma ANCL MeL M MLTR Mel eM Eee) ANRC oMR Lael etn Med MTU Tela WM er] NAC] ALL Cod} that ominous house covered in birds. Does anyone know any tricks for befriending wildlife? To be clear I'm looking for ways that won't put them in danger physically or anything that would change their diet and hurt cur in yee ee Or) Comers Err) Ces Lig eo Pr cL ea is eee Raw in-shell peanuts, too big for smaller birds.Dust with cayenne to discourage squirrel'n'such. Oe lCoT ue ROM -to1e] ol ae ete Me EcL Celia mo LR A platform that makes some good noise when you put out the peanuts (e.g., corrugated tin or fiberglass panel with posts at the corners), Try to keep a consistent schedule and quantity. If/when they bring you something, give ‘em a little something osteR- Ue MU ML RU EST oll ee moa em Dau A eM MUU ICRU le cel eee RT| RU-ly therm to rob people if you reward them for it. A Samo] Cian ae