Biblioteca Memetica

A collection of memes, curated by CJ Trowbridge.

Category: Papes - Old Maps Of The World -> This Meme

Old Map (91).jpg

gemma3-27b-vision

Okay, let's break down this fascinating early world map through the lens of the requested theoretical frameworks. It's rich material, so each section will be detailed.

Please Note: Applying these frameworks to a historical artifact like this involves interpretation and speculation. I'll provide what I feel are the most relevant angles within the constraints of image analysis and theoretical understanding.

1. Visual Description

This is a vividly colored, highly decorative world map dating to 1626 (as noted by the date at the top). It employs a circular, dual-hemisphere projection. The map is framed by elaborate allegorical figures and symbolic imagery:

  • Central Map: The core of the image is a detailed depiction of the known world at the time. Continents are recognizable, though shaped according to early modern understanding (e.g., the Americas are more elongated, Australia is largely unknown). Coastlines are rendered with intricate detail, showing cities and settlements.
  • Allegorical Figures: Around the map are portraits of European aristocracy. Their representation and positioning appear hierarchical, suggesting power and patronage.
  • Symbolic Imagery: The map is filled with visual metaphors. At the top, the elements—earth, water, air, and fire—are depicted. In the corners are smaller scenes representing the sun and moon and winds and rain. These scenes serve to both decorate and symbolize the map's attempt to explain and dominate the natural world.
  • Text & Inscriptions: The map is covered in text in English, describing places, noting resources, and providing commentary. The lettering is ornate and adds to the overall decorative quality.
  • Stylistic Features: The map is characteristic of the early 17th century, with a focus on ornamentation, a detailed but not necessarily entirely accurate depiction of geography, and a clear emphasis on European exploration and dominance.

2. Foucauldian Genealogical Discourse Analysis

This map is a powerful example of how knowledge and power are intertwined. Using a Foucauldian lens, we can analyze how this map constructs the "world" rather than simply representing it:

  • Discursive Formation: The map is not simply a neutral recording of geography; it's a product of a specific historical "discourse"—the European worldview of the early 17th century. This discourse is characterized by a belief in European exceptionalism, the pursuit of exploration and trade, and the desire to categorize and control the natural world.
  • Power/Knowledge: The map exemplifies Foucault’s central idea of Power/Knowledge. The ability to create and disseminate this map conferred power. It allowed Europeans to define and claim territory, establish trade routes, and legitimize colonial endeavors. The "knowledge" contained within the map wasn’t objective truth, but a constructed reality that served the interests of those who created it.
  • Genealogy of Control: Tracing the “genealogy” of this map would reveal how earlier maps, nautical charts, and European conceptions of the world informed its creation. It would also show how this map, in turn, shaped future exploration and colonization, creating a lineage of control over land and people.
  • Subjectification: The map contributes to the "subjectification" of the world – meaning it creates subjects (both in the land depicted and the European viewers) through the categories and representations it uses. The depiction of some lands as “unknown” or “savage” is not simply descriptive; it defines those places and their inhabitants.

3. Critical Theory

Applying Critical Theory (rooted in the Frankfurt School) highlights the ideological functions of this map:

  • Ideology & Representation: The map is deeply ideological. It normalizes the European worldview as the worldview. The map's emphasis on European exploration, cities, and power centers obscures the perspectives and experiences of people in other parts of the world.
  • Commodification & Control: The map implicitly frames the world as a resource to be exploited. The depictions of trade routes, settlements, and resources reveal the capitalist drive for expansion and profit that underpinned European exploration.
  • Domination & Othering: The map contributes to the "Othering" of non-European cultures. The depiction of unfamiliar lands as "unknown" or "savage" reinforces the idea of European superiority and justifies colonial domination. The selective focus on European powers and trade routes reinforces their position as central and powerful actors on the world stage.
  • The "Enlightenment" & its Dark Side: This map was created during the Enlightenment, a period supposedly characterized by reason and progress. However, Critical Theory compels us to recognize that the Enlightenment was also entangled with colonialism, exploitation, and the subjugation of non-European peoples. This map embodies that tension.

4. Marxist Conflict Theory

From a Marxist perspective, this map is a visual representation of the geopolitical struggles and economic interests of the early 17th century:

  • Class Struggle & Colonialism: The map reflects the expansion of European capitalist powers and the associated exploitation of labor and resources in colonized territories. The emphasis on trade routes and settlements demonstrates the drive for profit that fueled colonial ventures.
  • Material Conditions & Power: The map's depiction of resources (e.g., spices, gold) highlights the material conditions that underpinned the power dynamics between Europe and the rest of the world. The ability to map and control these resources was crucial for maintaining European dominance.
  • Imperialism & Territorial Control: The map is a visual manifestation of imperialism. The depiction of territorial claims and colonial possessions demonstrates the desire of European powers to control land and resources.
  • The Role of the State: The map likely received patronage from a national state. This reflects the active role of the state in sponsoring exploration, establishing colonies, and protecting trade routes.

5. Postmodernism

A Postmodern reading would focus on the map’s constructed nature and its inherent instability:

  • Deconstruction of "Truth": Postmodernism questions the idea of objective truth. This map, from that perspective, isn't a "true" representation of the world, but a constructed narrative shaped by European biases and perspectives.
  • The Simulacrum: The map can be seen as a "simulacrum"—a copy that has no original. It's a representation of a representation, detached from any "real" world.
  • Fragmentation & Relativism: The map's selective focus on certain regions and the omission of others reflect the fragmentation and relativism inherent in all attempts to create a totalizing representation of the world.
  • The Death of the Author: Attributing a single "truth" or "intention" to the mapmaker is problematic. The map is a product of its time, shaped by a multitude of factors and perspectives.

6. Queer Feminist Intersectional Analysis

This is the trickiest application, given the map's historical context, but important:

  • Silencing of Indigenous & Non-European Voices: The map, like many historical representations, erases or marginalizes the experiences of Indigenous peoples, women, and other marginalized groups. The focus on European exploration and domination obscures the perspectives and agency of those who were colonized.
  • Gendered & Racialized Cartography: The map, created in a patriarchal and colonial society, likely reinforces existing gender and racial hierarchies. The representation of certain regions as "savage" or "unknown" may be linked to racialized and gendered stereotypes.
  • Erasure of Non-Normative Sexualities & Gender Identities: The map, created in a society that did not recognize or tolerate non-normative sexualities and gender identities, erases any evidence of their existence.
  • Intersectional Oppression: The map highlights the intersectional nature of oppression. Indigenous women, for example, would have faced multiple forms of discrimination based on their gender, race, and colonial status.

Important Note: These are just interpretations. Different scholars might emphasize different aspects of this map, and further research could reveal additional layers of meaning. I've aimed to provide a reasonably thorough analysis based on the available image and the provided theoretical frameworks.

First Seen

2015-12-18T09:30:09+00:00

tesseract-ocr

=e a = — Tee Li ore ICANIEW AND ACCVRAT MAP OF THE WORLD diane soy tll Datrnine lift Divers mht mations $e bre mae Eh > ISS —— | oe 1 ey = ee = Ja { V7 “LE pees Te Se ——— =e a NY “Ge BP 2 es rR — gee anus ee HY, go BONG ery = THEW = vay VEE 2 = nae SOCAN NER sre EWORTD. y rN bo PE : Ge BRON, SON — enbs- — es pV ——— Se er) Fe Fee ee Voges RIO genes ee ee ES. — D —————— eed Wey fe Se EVER SO} ON Ne =e Nn IFES eS — ee ——= wae ie: bi ie. [Ms TERNOD SON wa pee = cay ee ESS ae cae e Ey, Reid (ot Bye a OE oe Z ee SS ape ——— Draw ee a 3} tee Ve Sarat iE -— oa eee vs WE == 12. ai Sea AF WLS ae acl. 2 Bases = Be LG v= WATER ———— accord 2 HAN Ka ih Bo aa oN c= Ope Ly = aay tay eee | I TES X ey sac fl 8 ea ie At i, we eG o = Ss SS od truest D poe LORS ce Be 22 ss fe ree gh pee == ae yee elcrivtts ee HS ROSS = Se i Hf EG Pon aa oid NG Seg i oS we eS ——— iptions I, ae zs Db : We SS eee, s) [oe Sue EN 4 Ses We =) - - Se oh eS “ag ie om de SS — Co. z eee e222 = See yg hd eae = ae BAe os a> eS Se =e Gat ees Ly: “ee S a oe UErIes ——= 4 ee SSS Ss aie Li es SS poe a eh SS: << % eee ley ENE SWS 2 os = te ee Zz me = a See = LS = i oy REX Ficaber! Br oe “lar | eS ¥ . E. — Ss ah 32 as | 2x SSS LP) AK = 33 S = wil ag Wh asf Bee Boos Ce Rae. SK a ARETE. aE Be UG Obfe eS ea Ata aamast Se gE oR t sa eS =| fey =e Pee : eas RN C2 » — uations ee ee Hee ay gee E ee : Row = L& Vag ft a Gk we aS Pe —, \ ities § debe = Sy Se y have b : ee rer ia | ¥ Sg \ i, cee SN! AS @ Ata s wos aa ¥ ee ee se a oC SPE eene mad oom | : Sea} Bg & SO 2 BS (RAS es aT es Rush ee Ht Cg Ke Ay a. AUR ie ‘am So = Y ild Pee ia 3 ee EO ay = é b E ; ree Dil , Wi Sy SS Dae fy i RS eS — ai HWE a hae se g OR a es. = Jigs 2) sy = Sy (aa gh 16 =e ot Sl iF ome Lp Ah, BS Souk ea ———s Ste sbera o ef fe fet ASS es Lee hy eae aed Eee on =. CE BAF are of tie ar St 26 \l AN WLS / a . eratinle: fi Fin eee Ty SS =a a pe Se i; ef) Sho)\y PO ed ot z Ay | ea a rangers. ' iM di yy Se OD) eety sar 7 / Pies Sas 7 er Se eRe Ub SS lease GN Zana 1 Sade Ki eS : (oe gee ii Ca ————— een | eee: J c & s frit | Awe WETS ie "i a Sh aD fe Se <i (Vasa! 3 . a ES eo bite ge iy) CL ss Sf Ee ee “4 e lis OR je eee es fee: (od chi Wen ort A? - SER B\="e aie Eee eae FA eH \t SS Srey so ae Nae Ozu tii igi ies <a eet a ely ad Sf TH sia wae a) aie Pees ante iy ~ Sa 7A age PE Me CONGay lt A t Bow Wwe ce Ngai: ee Cz iV =f 6 ——— = a : } oe fod Bert Ue ue of cedlid ae Chive f oct Macks By Po ae WS Ee CAF, [raed oe sah Bhd peeks 4 Ee Le oN vey Tae [a : = == i Ii *& Nene Ses yy \\\e SoM ep SS Le. eer Ve . yt A Co RH 7 Ae ~S dese flere oH extet D at ie ae oS Ss JEI\ Bc ay et Gs a = So = he PEN Se — EE ae S35 ES ae (eas =| Ei ky i be A ez eter Na NE By SW | sept LPS BEY a a Ke fe! La aA, Risah Page be i | a: Hf Be ect Ws ERA SSE Aan BS Soe a We a mete § p Sy ee [= | 6 oe sel? = a9 yee <a a Se HL lay //f aor ic A/ ——- ae BS co NG wee SY Li ZS as See fies A <> BZ SS Sih } y le or/N ey [Petes Aine ee ? RWIS Ne ——-- ve ines b= —s Za o> a ipo ; TS ey = | Hi i i] e pA eel Se MF Te fe Oa ees Z D rN SOS Jessy rae tS 28 fF EF A gies eee =e Sr aS = Ae y — ip f/f A (Beas: tl gee ae Ct dae ages oe y << eee BOL = ae Jose Ss ak ES pay a ih Hi i : ae na é ie ee ee Rae i, . NP Seip Se eet 7 ose Za. ae Se Seer a = oD eer 1. Gt Gre i in fh fet ye ae aah =f eo iyo oa eee XS = a eis dpe = Sag # i aS ul cf Me Zoe i i f dL Raiae. Pa Tee aids a SEES Oe LO Bee sti F > Va _——s Z a” Ds ge” ex : a See NN cae A PEL The | A 1p ae Fa a [rte 2 Ne Ban 2 Figen ee a 7 ee rece Ti F, oe ne iy Zig NS je ie if WAL P / ae a eee ease ak Lae oy a 0G Fy Fou and CES epi ALAN ee = See Sa Fa | f U é a? \s nee oe eee RY oS wy x? ified Ei Beh ie = ee SSE i H i ud ee CAN ee Ne BAe Ba ses ee re 2 es O Tre 7% \ Je eS f \\ 2, ae a os Be, So i | A = ke, ae eras penal Ne rel ce , ; pent aS se ae Ney i Se. eifet Pel | I = oS ss 2 . pee aN | f AR = aur Sf pee Ele os eo QUIK hein WY fs mm” A Dy AEE a Bee Pies ML Hee “lis ss PS ees le gy ae ti H fy Ease Ide Coral ba a Oz : a ae ee il Ss Fait whee 9 q Cun a ES: eee a Be, APE bo as Re a =1¢ i H i Res Pees Phe eo ¥ at aed 4 of’ Cre Sra [ee RL : Sy = Seto ge ee St Ley eh ess eee | ey (y Prices. 3x0 (eee ve “We Pee TESS = 8. : : s FE Ae Byer: ee Sere 3 is hy Sr OR Aue ke Baye caheree P eN : Mm eae See east ieee tae ge sd six, ey tins ee D ae % fe Eo See ew) A Sit A Z > ON 7 rr are = ee ee [i W Be / nS Meo Se Soe: pea fat SOAS ves =a | } | B Sa sites : ee | sey pes = ee ees 4 4 oe Se * os, ee ee wee eel ¥ Ti a Ae oe oA, > ee E eRe } E =e aes aie a fe Sl sr Eee ON & Fr Oo op oe teeta ee SY PAGE ee Po EASES te a fm a S SS F A 4 - The | pratt | ean ye feet a Mie setae Lage f eS i pene es ise eee aoe ee be Kee: trea Sy Ne Ge : H\\ 5 ‘a peice oe ure voyage SAGES if ec EM \/ red ey Smeg AGS A Oe. oa a | v {\ a a | ial eee i eT Om or 5 : Soh Se Gi peridds or 5: =F A va Oe Seeds Bante fet ies ele fi Sse pe Le Sa ce Bae s ele baat? ‘S $ \ | ret tht pene ge | aS a ey SN ha elf aa ol tee wie Eee a Le tad care Bee peor Nee ud eae a Sees - ees cea eet fies We Nl Ane Ne TOS PS i A la § ao ae a] glee are ee oe Sea ce ae fae pay oe Ve es Se RNS Gar x Pt 3): 4 red © \Greeetlead ral ae \ aha ee ae BPSD tone * ae N oH , Sass Se a ic ie ine Pa Rana pliclag on ee a RN hee tis 8 “S\ ae: rei By ss J \ A. . defied Teaytore He iulied 3 a oe e < Sey OR El H Peo SA ies PEs ae ve as ee Ba see pal Ties \X JO se ax* Bo as LY i y oe se a ected | = ¢ ea Bret T HE mene? Be nied ET Fae bem opr ss ~t emate sta ce fee RAS Bere far: er Wie: ae fel fs pears ee ras pores | be T <tap Ze Ae ee one Be Aiea ae Dea oN \Y is He’ e = t fastens 2 aS iene : E Rie a ees, oe eat, eet Sapte ey fhe ea.0 Aare cot oe e ac PX z 7 3 » o Hy ‘ ome as shame ees pained oe i eres a : EH sae [ees ee E Sine age seeds Meeps aa Bn S\N ars Ae ae ys aN Et F a \ Fan = | ee Be ayy asens: res | ES Se. ao eo ne ae ae Dae j 1 0 4 oye ae Pe A a= ontop Sige). ot 1s SF ae y fe gna NEP ae 2G eee | Alsedel AS SA See of o ‘| | \ ae! ay Et 2 oe i cue Li a: | Sed oe os Serr RAGE pe oi % i AY Bie Cp er ee oe gid Sar FF oe Fie sl = oo Frio : Be ag Ss AY ih hi . tifeee tl ete oh See eA oe Sf ee acre or the eta Aree i ae — gee Re Se Za gO X fi eh oe es oy IP Ree een Herons Pe Nyse “a aaa fees fee ES pee ee A —— 0 a i A Rares if Meee : Of re See ee a TH Sather ae fy tied in? Ci RES we Aramis Ete ae ce ae ie 4H : e\\ Te con a P att ae fan ry: See. ae Y q raaae gee i Lee gos Cte) fis A a ie gp iteve: \I ENN ae i 1g — x goer < \ a) Petites Te ate at eas & sy H Bit Ties Paine seep ef ate pr ee i ND dt at eer SOS eB a | le ar % D eine See. fe Fru (Bak ee as sey — a eae eooy Hi a eee, aie ee shat ay ew Ber a CEN ge G : m ! = \ AY . Leite eka iae ae ae sey Le pa. ci z fe Ls ee ole gh pork toe es * Sel . he Be MA Ok x geen the Beene al | ee PANASS i oS oo BM* re ieee won : ile b = ee eee \ck ee \\ 1 as fia 4 NR Se Ad coped «bes ie, als 2S eE if Rio aaa ae, ae ae [es a a use. Ree ii ee oe # = oe SS = 1 Lea Fae kzi Be |: Heme te” ‘ rer ie: BRE. ee / Oe ae ea She Ag = ee eanes eS Mano a al Se aes ae, Eithae poten th eve bie ae Ss iy AY yee b ae * = Hid toate ne: Drake | ase ee reap <= = if IS XK Sp ne = seen ae re ep Sete se ee ee | read al | ey = Cl fate Ai ‘ Q a Candi elicary and fecsi aT Bere] Sa, yy Ay AF cain osgoom 2 Aes Pe spade Fz ise [ise ees velox ec L He ee Bin SP » a LEE ae ek / Se “Bay, i / =) ail ai i Be ——— ‘i cane io al TH Se | aS er sci mitt ; jaa Ra So M — defives5p Foie b= sa = - ee : Se eS seed See es E J er! — eT SU eae : S — oneal e Le ae A hf d ANY ee sabe Ke ee =] iN see) eeepe G : ae oT. OR G — i pie / : Heh Me, ‘ iN eo Se eee pee ee Ss See er | He SEAR Le a z 7 \ oar e ay es ‘a yr ry EM ie oe & 1 ‘ee | “ Sad nN ze sf le ANS dps == Rb et = Ts ‘ Be (BE is poe e Rie as Dy Rew ; : Poy fF Se H Hi aN wate eee ot AON Ca af ae \ BEN “i fof Le \ iat aA j i | — a = s-A 4 aie Se : = . x ci | “eg ao _ f/ y a \ anny S | Bee hime 1} ; i} = oe) ee SEG Peas i Ay / <> A Pe Pe) go sou ; » \ a t EIA : Sch LENT. A i | Zam eee he ee ae Xi he. 4? Ry i srenili W\% a j ink E | HIDOL ~ Hy i | ee [fe fae A Las : Ly. rt. ‘ |p Ca [efit ies | ff) | Hy 7 Hp SS = Pe S | ascir the af ge iy foBseN Dy Pic zag | . A igetg feat | [ A HP bhi jig as Fe aS. > F S etsy ae gp ay gs SE ve f Weide Re. Ape / ] f Hie 2 LATS SS Gres See I BY ML i SY “t SS R Bite: Be io tind part * f / [ iy eee TIEN 1 3) ke oie FSR RNS ee iS ot Vy ls LE Ry 12 TNO 2 fithace: Bf pee Lpartafohe Bi f | i NG ae ee a. = SS o eet zie a a5 4 GF Loge i Os La RE Dh, She Count rato ) { cathe fie i te. ] / f / A He in \ fo Lees SS Se ae AE ME OS Sp canes > <> _ bee iate ps Ee me, te epted. ola \\/ . / L : lL = ee Sa SS Se FR 0 Sf aa <a ~ 3 GN [gg > ye a oN aS bates AS HN? cep i aa / f sf A / f if eS aa IG = iS — = : = BE gf ; iit ae ee eE Ketrcdeain ; RX Ge. amoditier cael / g & i i 2 — eS SS y= — a Fs ae i: ‘fig E> 5 eS ee lw, © 2 ay, Sebi Cee IX / / ee i iy oe le eo re oe i Hee! soe La ea < a é Shee ( SS JOSS ni) Tx / ) TE ‘ by / - oO = oe = we eh aE , eas ee oe = << Coe or Se << UY | £ fe : RN PRY ig GS sat Lifer Ee NES Ey Ne ce =e 2 Se — 0" a j Ne ag in Es ye ee Ve as \A iN O eee de : Tera | SSS Of te a ee, i sk eos a er. 2-2 i Si! a H ate ‘aie St Ke Fe Poa Bo NES Need WW n. x Meas oN =| Sate nae SoG ma ANE Sey Pe be Ree a S mG el \ oy A = Vy \4 / y = ey “nee. Se oA ok fo JER eer ce Ses \ Be tEKes 2 \ pee =i i ae ma fe 1 ry CL a vs 4 =p Jf ——] sores oe ie ip ae 4 »' tS a He r Pg S| ACs See Aa | = SS 1} ; Cc 4 i = aad © 2 LZ We aa aly ww. ei a® Nel at. Tee ae ‘ 2) es os \\\ | \ DN D < ie \ ee eS I SS BOR AS / i. BE ® eS Qe ae tea | WS aj oa Mi ne y eg : 2 ae oe = =a ae Wes | fe hte aN ena SN Naan Sie iG iB: — = FF, ser QU) \ Sr sc Cy = eas = SP Sa 3 a \. re Ps ae at ee a | = =e pea \ VO XS “le x = ees i a Sa J SS Rs PA ER ee aaa re Rud oe Be pA ad eee ee AS 4 Le ee Fe ee = ae i iN ORES aes me Ws a= (g a % 2 z “i SSS ae oS z || | a Dies pS SOS Le EO, = LPI: ie ci Se a € ee = gt f: Se a i Sea Fe — < 2 es is = Ef ; 5 = PS Fh age SSS ZA es hg ee oe a soe & el = > * 1g = == BS SS eS = ioe || mee = 3 + > NAS i ae = se N 5 | ols ual see Se fe — « y 2! Sah lead All ve pd Pe) Qo RS stent pe: | 2 ga ee a ae _S ey SSS ea SS Se = Ba I coe cr ea ‘a cc See === ad | Ad — ae i UE SS = —————— Lipse ; | CY =) ee ae Ss sneer ioe | posse a iy

llama3.2-vision

The meme is a humorous illustration of a world map, but with a twist. The image shows the world as it would look if it were flat and two-dimensional, with the Atlantic Ocean stretching across the middle of the map, separating the Americas from Europe and Africa. The text at the top reads "A new and Accurate Map of the World" and the bottom reads "Drawn according to the latest discoveries & observations".

Back to Papes - Old Maps Of The World