First Seen
2015-12-18T09:30:09+00:00
simple-description (llama3.2-vision_11b)
This meme is an image of an old map of the world, specifically a 17th-century map of the Americas and the surrounding regions. The map is titled "Nova Totius Terrarum Orbis Geographicae" and features illustrations of various regions and cultures, including a large map of the Americas and smaller maps of Europe, Africa, and Asia. The text at the top of the map reads "Nova Totius Terrarum Orbis Geographicae" and the image is surrounded by illustrations of various cultures and regions, including a map of the Americas, a map of Europe, a map of Africa, and a map of Asia.
detailed-analysis (gemma3-27b-vision)
Okay, let's analyze this fascinating 17th-century map using the requested theoretical lenses. Here’s a breakdown, hitting each section where relevant.
1. Visual Description
This is a beautifully detailed, hand-colored world map titled "Nova Totus Terrarum Geographica ac Hydrographica Tabula" (New Geographical and Hydrographical Map of the Whole World). It appears to be a double-hemisphere projection, representing the Eastern and Western Hemispheres. The detail is quite remarkable for its time; coastlines are clearly delineated (though not entirely accurate by modern standards), rivers are traced, and major cities and settlements are marked.
* Aesthetic & Style: The map is ornate. Decorative cartouches (elaborate frames) house titles, explanatory notes, and legends. The map is richly colored with different shades to delineate land masses and bodies of water. There are small vignettes around the perimeter, depicting indigenous people, animals, ships, and sometimes scenes of colonial activity.
* Projection: As mentioned, a double-hemisphere projection. This impacts the size and shape of land masses, inevitably introducing distortion.
* Content: The Americas are prominently featured, reflecting the peak of European exploration and colonization. Africa, Asia, and the known parts of Australia are also included, though often depicted with less detail. The Pacific Ocean is relatively large and largely uncharted ("Terra Incognita").
* Materiality: It's a printed map, likely engraved on copperplate, indicating it was meant for a relatively educated audience (given the cost of production and access to such materials). The paper appears aged and delicate.
2. Foucauldian Genealogical Discourse Analysis
This map is a powerful site for Foucauldian analysis. It's not simply a “neutral” depiction of the world; rather, it produces knowledge, establishes power relations, and defines "truth" about the world.
Discursive Formation: The map belongs to a specific discursive formation – early modern cartography. This isn’t just about technical skill; it's about the rules* of representation, the accepted conventions of mapmaking, and the ways in which knowledge about the world was constructed at that time. What is included, excluded, emphasized, or minimized is not arbitrary but shaped by these rules.
Power/Knowledge: The map demonstrates a strong power/knowledge relationship. The European creator(s) of the map held the power to define and represent the world. This representation wasn’t simply “accurate”; it constituted* the world as knowable according to European standards and values. For example, labeling regions, naming cities, and drawing borders all asserted a form of control and legitimacy.
Archaeology & Genealogy: Analyzing the map genealogically would involve tracing the historical conditions* that made this specific representation possible. What earlier cartographic traditions did it build upon? What political, economic, and religious forces shaped its creation? How does it differ from maps made in other parts of the world?
* Normalization: The map normalizes a particular worldview. European dominance, the concept of "discovering" lands, and the imposition of European names and boundaries all contribute to a normalization of colonial power structures.
3. Marxist Conflict Theory
From a Marxist perspective, the map reveals the inherent conflicts tied to early capitalism and colonial expansion.
* Material Conditions: The map is a product of a specific historical moment characterized by the rise of mercantilism and the pursuit of colonial wealth. The detailed mapping of trade routes, resource-rich areas (e.g., spices, gold, silver), and potential colonial territories indicates the map’s function in supporting capitalist expansion.
* Class Conflict: While not directly depicted, the map implies class conflict. The wealth generated by colonial exploitation benefited European elites while subjecting indigenous populations to subjugation, forced labor, and economic exploitation.
Imperialism: The map is a visual manifestation of imperialism. The division of the world into colonial territories and the emphasis on European dominance reflect the exploitative relationship between colonizers and colonized. The map doesn't show the impact of colonization on* the colonized, only the perceived opportunities for European profit.
* Ideology: The map serves as an ideological tool, legitimizing colonial domination by presenting it as a natural or inevitable process. The map’s representation of the world reinforces a particular power structure and obscures the violence and exploitation inherent in colonial relations.
4. Postmodernism
A postmodern reading would challenge the map's claims to objectivity and truth.
* Deconstruction of Grand Narratives: The map participates in a “grand narrative” of European exploration and dominance. A postmodern approach would deconstruct this narrative, exposing its biases, contradictions, and the ways in which it marginalizes other perspectives.
* Subjectivity of Representation: Postmodernism emphasizes the subjectivity of all representation. The map is not a neutral reflection of reality but a constructed interpretation of the world, shaped by the worldview of its creator.
* The Absence of the "Other": The map often depicts indigenous people as exotic "others," reducing them to simplified stereotypes or representing them solely in relation to European interests. This highlights the map's failure to represent indigenous knowledge, cultures, and perspectives.
Simulacra & Hyperreality: The map can be seen as a simulacrum*—a copy without an original. The map’s representation of the world is not the world itself but a mediated representation that increasingly obscures the lived realities of those represented.
5. Queer Feminist Intersectional Analysis
This is a more challenging area for a 17th-century map, but a queer feminist intersectional lens can still reveal hidden biases and power dynamics.
* Gendered Spaces: The map doesn't explicitly depict gender, but the emphasis on exploration and conquest reflects a patriarchal worldview. The absence of women from the narratives of exploration reinforces traditional gender roles.
* Colonial Sexuality: Colonialism involved complex dynamics of race, gender, and sexuality. The map obscures the ways in which colonial encounters involved sexual violence, exploitation, and the imposition of European sexual norms.
* Erasure of Indigenous Gender and Sexuality: The map erases the diversity of gender and sexual identities within indigenous communities. The imposition of European norms would have suppressed and marginalized indigenous expressions of gender and sexuality.
* Intersection of Power: A queer feminist intersectional approach highlights the ways in which race, gender, sexuality, and class intersect to shape power relations in the colonial context. The map reinforces a power structure that privileges European, male, heterosexual dominance.
In conclusion:
This map is far more than a simple depiction of the world. It's a complex cultural artifact that reveals power dynamics, ideological assumptions, and historical conflicts. Applying these theoretical lenses allows us to move beyond a surface-level reading and critically examine the map's implications for understanding the history of colonialism, power, and representation. Each framework provides a different angle on the same object, enriching our understanding of its meaning and significance.
simple-description (llama3.2-vision)
This meme is an image of a vintage world map with various illustrations of mythological creatures and historical figures. The text at the top of the image reads "Nova et Nova et Nova et Nova et Nova" which is Latin for "New and New and New and New" and is often used to describe something that is constantly changing or updating. The image is likely being used to express frustration or annoyance at the constant updates or changes in a particular situation.
tesseract-ocr
[rare re 2 = : i 5 = Ry Se ee eee — : be ar a SS a [ a oe a YY aa. Ny Ny Pe LS & Sait ne fees 4 = P= et 118 E Ln 8 D2 eek ES om ee [Carreuna | Pee Foe oh i) ee Logp Da ; or : vr 4 A. A ee a Ci = hia eh eat Y Se : f TSN Fane - - =a Pa | Craveres [Loo —- ye a ae = (e CNG i Ve 3 ae 5 ie fl Sp aS BE g a : % Z = rs Eno th . 5 NN S547 a i \ai(g fi Beh 5 ios ooo ae , Sipe 8 = " . = ° me Sa Si — Vik Oc ae IL Oe f : i) ba fi We . a Gel ae del \ a ie Fh eg % z SEIS pe aes c| ORF || aia ye |G | a aNe| 3 ah) yah ey Es Nae Es) iP I oe | ee ia Se Sepa WON ! ins all ae i. a baa OM de ie | | a) rae Fc ‘sees bi DC PRs Mo! AN | j Pam : | ah, be ell ‘ e@), ) OA Ke > Ses | the Pi ao S| i Ng RL || aa f# aes Ly = 4 we Kl: =) @ | ee | | 1] BENE Se &é yp Ua Taro, | es ONS: | Me 2 t | <2 2, _. SA UF ON goss f Ass ; y) ets ry) ae = 3 fa si a H Er tae SAIS ! ss NN S | eg ic N \ a aS ar ie == | Beck) = een ON aS Ih eR ss f i LN Hen Ae eae | I; Sea deere | Sree) fe AS | are See | gee ee 3 | = ae “ a e Rowe os : SR: | eee : a) fae ees J el eae a SS We me 4 SS RY J | ey FN ae ay Se FN rr Skee : EF °/NO\ 3 s BE ey ah edad eb pan Secs |S We PAD CVS ie } AW OP a | P Pye SW NES es Pa > . = = — ile Milas SS ait Be) A = Cx ey DR “to ae | fg (Pe Cg: Lee: geea/ he / a “ah Pa ad b. = = | 5 a) a ee Ss Se. BI a 3 ies Eich e EE ONE Rrra “hey fey ee ay NSPS Pes) a see ses |< ay ERRARUM O @ Bee es eee eK ee | Bee ie, a. ms | Ls ikea oe al eee 7 7 SS RBIS GEOGRAPHIC a, ae mei ee Be Ke ba Ben Si) 8 sai bed) | - i | / a | v Ac ae ed — = A ; , aaa Se es ae Nia aS (ae Ie i eae : FE of | | SSS H = A SNe Wie ee b= Furor Se | - || Val Sepp) | g : | | | eee) | 26: NVISEER RSREERE AC HYDROGRAPHICA ae BE | pay bam |g | ale Ea = = Sa GS ae aah By es | Ss £9) pie gages (Hs f =f | tng an eri alls te | | a sila Sa 7A Gy & | | EN sega. OD na 2 <| oe pee anlar: | me Pe ‘Zl ore a Ge BS & 4 | I ot lophorc coin Boh ae | ‘Pliucasce shee tg ha porelate fs | | Lo Ae 3 _ Loo im OF | ae GE Lirhosnentin ee | | see | el | ly | eee | fe < a < leech mo f Pe as een MESS | | le F Re Ke | | arr: | Mr Mare) Gracia 1 eae | | / a) f mo fiean eeaay yA DNase A Feceum distur, return quod de aomine ik : Pe | | | | an ci oe i <a # sf ee A tia i iaghe ey es | | Mane et | SARE es OcrANuS teN.. | | |g BF se |. ie elders fe en | JR Ra crea fn a Wy ai a eee tee ee 321567. 0h7 4 Bags j 3 | bs Sete | So be | | qeNE tg F comix a bo fi bon, ea es ony |: sh if : geal areas Ei } ke ‘> Ly aeaeed | end ance SF | ise 77, me IGA lv sd gan oy ae a || i : Be ects idgsConmediar ere We FS 3 a pee Meer? Sessa | I Pines eyes | jee es IN wz eo} ea. dersa> Te if ij) sae [ Wai A = Ro x Ulla, gud eu ahi a Tas S | sel Tae. i Yas 3" Vee nef SEPT EIN ap] leaker os ee Nova sob hpactegee AG eS nn = | a. LS ry ee E SL i ture Leas Maire a | (far | “| Ase Meee i je Os aes Boers? | Ze x Cpe ee. | / = . bee Pe ees |< ik f Apian CEN EB Cui pe pies Hattie ie epee SA ee | a ale eae | OT Bipemetiinee | ( (SY g 5 — ele dee H 1S Sax = a ee AE eee ha a fd ation See SA Wer aL SEI oar ake ee ee | bee (G } a Se H i mm, AN al ————ee— Le Pva 5 tee eA spo SASL Ee IE fare gree 7 J | } 8 mney Lo d ah ‘ fe | i ; , : Sop ext a ee) a Reser te ieee “A |s staf thee seen a ica. ce eee est on ee | Ee a aren i] ee od oa oo ~q 1 CN tape adrane eee | es — rk nee yly sorgae NO vhf an alert DN a aay orn 3 : | 7 : os é | | aA Ba ge lk seit aise) OH tas Tea Se. S i Apel Ns POS SWAN Motgomy 717 ANG —+t | oe fs AN me eS : ON | oe cian —+ Shinn eee tS Gi age — ey Wess eg Celt ESR Y or Niel Dag, pees ae oe 4 wed : ee at Ea i t ee f ae ys | OS Sex . on fe H ae ee Fae RP Seed kyu meee ey : een Re = S. a, ee | \ Eee, Amer) s | ge aoe pins hy ie # age epee are st Te || ae || Sok pad re | ies SBF" ao tc & £5) aes = | Rel Tene Spee | 2 to, reg | eam EY cae en pee Rl eee BE PTE LE AG bee actual ah = q ge SS tallied ; | ae ye] yEPTEN : ives Sone) ined Soom poe Oc eanas aaa Bt Sa hea rN aes aah ee iy iF ey Da trsnnl See ae ys ea AS. Sse aa ae Be R onari sal a4 liege | OT ee re ae DSS trecsen Bye yal a re sbi Sapo ee Sad a yy: we ae 2 RE Be anby St es. eee eee Sea REE tI ene spd ALTA EN SB telat 2 lian Sag BT] bs] If : & Ast A —— bear H a ke We | She t eBay Monta: ¢ i sce dentus j ae po a ee us See ey tee : a = , = a Cr A BEL eK en IS Lem Po wl, ofa ad pi iin Pt eas: Si Sid eaten | can soe Pea at iS eS pote = ) : hel y = : ‘ . oe eee - ge : a at ate eee ern eet ae g Fin og Teas ea ea hy oe | eye ae. = ee & GS la ez A Fe apc aoxR Nee wie ‘ ae poe WL “fe Bake eS (Aerie nies 55 : = Fa , i He eer | AES A J Ree ie feel se NT se at Papen ere Ses RR apie nl ete ao So ° Ha Rize | ah Snes Rae poe = See Sa eee STEP EY Be ES Os 7 a a | a He Bs S bel aA ye ia Segoe: BSc ae se a Roe nes ESTEE ag Foe er eae ieee fe pag Stee anes pgs eey a! ee ; aD 75 rege Baie cares Es 2) Sere < pid ig 49 Bere 1 sop Bik i | omer fess eee SAG Vase ata BOE fay eee ee Rickert Se i = Saye ang Eat + ie aN Sse 6 ea : se RE Ce ii io Res £5) Se =| ——~1 fhe Aegke taal Dae abuses Neo oe ogee ey Dee S rent, & Pons Se oH F ee Mee 4 ’ e ts =) 7 : oS ate pga ee oe aes ae Ne ea ae : “ Sissi essihent | Sevan ae ace Heri) [a did ee || PAS ey) ey | | ol Tapia cane Reamer Si Sea So Ree ae MAI Hoe wi ial antec eN aed ioe ber ete Boe eS [e Spey i fe oo Z2) : EA a y) ie 2 Si SS Ree a or Rath Re ee ae Ne seats alse thee eet ea BOS Se | s is 4 5 ci Hp ie a E i. de Ci balnt =— = SSS : es eters ge | Depeche A ee CaS) ah Fe sage? ; leas ge Ree eee ek feo ee SM at a Hana! i ah ! 2 ‘Pay 5 ce 3 7 ata ees (rel ES = H ee ee Ee ess oan laren Nae Se Fo a ees fie ater Techs Ca oe a Ui ie. poe a rT ip | Ee => oS a Ae ROE pete Be aoa Sees e ay oe EN ee ea. | ( ==, al Se eee | fe ee. iM 2 | hea ee See Nort” ae oS ee Sea es ee ey eh ee peas ao ‘ee EN | iis SUB <j oh =r Bee R | | ORS cass gs CS Sites ORT Hct eld Bae Hee Pula aig Ges ae Se ee s ee fee Rts (ec : Pee PAS a) ee eee ee se sz sf E|L ve eee = Sep | paneer erate ered A oe Sok ie : ee See Serer eae LACK Ee eee eee es dl : = — age | os eee is = 8 | 2 SE re eS ee Se Mare 8S pea 2 Beil | ey Ee ee i , : ec | oo a : acre le Ogre Dees cea) iNeed ke thor + =f ee Sate Treen ey Sept re Jee poe egy: Bi See | id 2A ve : mle 1 Poe akg ee ee DEER Se = el SEP Acaticum Mein he Og aoe BP Zr es ine || | enn a a ae . Eo ea | | | gene ee a dah Ws. Nw Saisie Bera ae ¢ ais oe aa =Be Gens oN? oa ae OT ee nar Het } € age = sali _ os a | ieee’ Cae i cae I SN SOS ee 72 rack Rove Sinus eo Sar AS SS ee EM, z 5 Seay eS teem | eel ES Oceurvd ee ee ee | ee Se. un pice ot |G ip ue GaN Sen |e ‘ end. Sa a ZiUR { Ze wees aN. ert ents te (i | ase Se ee ee hag eos wie? = Sie a p- AFRr Sa | a Se - ang. eiawint | | [ORR eerie Ni Ree Pec ccignss | HO can oS es fore aos? ga sarees ie es =) oe 2 ae af CANI <q H = eer | (Perrone! on fale, SO lg i | Me PS, ie re Ric oAN te ph ae e ez Dy tiler ee net SS a 2 : —— kee SS ee ate derober gee Re ea ge a ep eee pe ternawnnee 4 , = fl Ki ] . i Re MERIDIOPV A’ Pe Spi Petty MH opr peaks oe res a Hate) ie fee cone : ONS i ri <i scam =~ Lash i lacus Sa LSewasS DIOP AY ina oe a) ee sre ome Ree ons Gyo if See agp ania | M * mt vo | f aa H Se aa os - NO = pean Serr =e ian | ous Ratha ee EGA eta el cin | MA ae ° Pans | , ye ; KS oh e : Me ee, pe lA | MiuaRrE| S| oe Bae Po GE ieee H | : se Wa ee Pea ‘s wt a |DI ee | yw alne Posey | et ae aos ge hie BS | | Ah | ieee ee a oe | ae ee ee a ee H | Paine ut coats 1Y¥ eer Oe aS BEV : He RE NSIS S eee ae ta bat RR i ete co fe) (eS Ret eee = gay cera al fy See SS | | eae >. es Son fl : 3 ae 8 | | Toe =| See Poet a rey im iif es LS Se 8 Sa Perey ~~ Sd Le fe | ee | com cas 2p Ea sTInpral | Hl Se, ea re Vee : i = LR SESSA, DEF IC UM, a 2a eo ||. eee edie es eo St eee rarer : | | : z) | | . Re ; H ft ee. thor { | j Kinga a] ~ 0 ELLANICE rN a = wy i is aa ie : ee ee | la | ; | | | : hi g s - : ' Ses a im ee I SeTESS RES as = | | ah Pe | # Le | 4 : i ld is a i \ : of ee ,- i 1 ee \ P | ! eh Ae She e.| RS ab | | i fen At se Ee » ey : aa E a RS ce SA a | ee ee =e beri re | |: Gams =. | dic \ Se Hes ARE yo Ff EST See Pec rapens exter | eae 3 a nn | | tr ~ ae A / \ A : E 4 ik o aoe re a | BREN tun ain =| f LFovomk, eR ee | ak pe SO ‘ Hi (S48 & a hetennanca le hieetaed ie ESO fey PES fl oe sete Ih : eS | Jie ee pence mites [ete | le Ee LANs iy —— Lo i eis & Ab hati Fed I sa ee Taunt | Pare = | ss | Lge Y rk 2 oe @ ms fs beseec cy . A ee IN ee / poof | 5 rane | | 7 Be <i a AcE a AS ae ix . siya) g Ee Loy M [Sass fas Fed | Ne 1 s i | ee ff iY aa ~ See | | 46 SS ie Va Yy Og aahower| $e Be He aos ei / AGeeAeL | | ieee ee ae | eT A . P sich | : Se ser ee eS ge X | | (EA | U | fears ee IEE er} ae Hd CNPP i, 0 ne : ésh ae Loyd | ' fast H | | | pe rae Yt . "i , aie 5 y ot eS } d: (ey A | | Haaer SLesrentiret Hedassfiar pt VY . ie = =e _, —— fe fell m | Vee SE Cicediase Whos | | See o1 i ae erg (eS SY ay hee = aS mae eet EE eae w | Phe eer li ive oe aSSC/IT\ SST potas omen ee 5 a — — Fr, GALBA ay 284 354) see 9 7 U | Sot RA Ut § | T BE CtCUs { | %, xa A rt ry SS yj A Ss I a : “eae - -— E OTrHro §£ 30 334 aaa | ae > | N i a eh | St RY. 1. Wee oy HS SSainedre == a4 b Ree ge oe <_< : ae ee Fee A C.O°G> NII T A Eigehen St / stahis OX Ve iE DOSES eee bests} i oe Gay EERO = Soe [Virerxius § Sea (OTe Z “ = 2 I ifeber excudebar St / | \\\g tle = a 3 | me ay 1 we <S = ee pes) me) , a 2 Fa Sa f L me he [VesPastANUS] aoe ae & 2 SES { Get | \ Xt Y BS re ae, Pa Ne | ih Shee le, il Le Lp a En, f i ee ee | Trevs’ f ————— a SSE Sf = Ro ae —— eats a 4 4) = << = pe ate) | (he Aiea q WA Fie i ae a eo: TTS eas H > | Ve (GE y nel a =e | \ fh fe Auge (page f Dy Cae Ss & = Rr SS WW [Dosrtranus] r ele ii See et ren pee AS i | | PNG Cos Ge | ey 1 . c : Li Kes AG 7 rae ~ | Ne Pes Soap o/s) | cea » Oe Vi ank we ghee. = re Ee ey ie east | WE aes Ay VS ea ey oN FESS a i . CreEewS ~~ aa \ \ 5 QP Awesrca =P aS ey, each | a, a SEs ey Nes a) “Ep ‘i e See? Wf | Gee Yon fe | Vee i & ao RICA a 7 = 4 A er 33 Naa ole a Re AGA ae ak i FF \ Se ree f 4 AS Seti Re, || See ee Ga f tae e _ > % i ICT Vee, 5 = =4 | a : Se eas | a Ree a Ga ee an Lage : eK IO, t a pee =) es mar LP ea. \\Sen ee Ss 2 ee : (Se gS ee So ee Oy aM BS Fe EO bee OS 4 ee es Le . aria ee Pee t ieee eee Ras aay D | ieice.. ) \ ase te on ee é i ae i f =A el oS 7 Se aes SF AW OS PER Og ee WI oh: aaTy 5 ee nee) E & ge \ oa SS i igs ae »S ie Ci »* eine, Hee a) a Co see En ts Laie Se os ee | 8 Gr Hon weasel. | (PRS AS i Ue \ We Saat Ge alse a | en ere ei aT py fae 03) ee cre.) oe SB . Peg ee) 17 [PRY ax ae pees cae bs Sibel | Sites ji SNCs es beeen ” pa a —s BD ses Norra? borat Ge Staas e (Ee yp ae (PS eae) Be iy gS BP rye aie) | 1 ae we SP 2 é = pee Sa es P| Ec a = fe | PS: <A / prea SY | ie prea ae Pa! We aN se aE — Amir ATP NS he! (paws ee es Se Alay pit aie oe ag : ee cae tos cart faery Se Reser! es ie Pa ss} ee Se ney ie Ss i ee i Bic speed per i me Ne ye as Ua ipa ( meres € ke ae ae Z a Oe 6 a Rey ee a4 US : PAs et EON Rea an ¥ Se S = ee. a Sn ee SS ee en | Pi Sp eM eat