First Seen
2015-12-18T09:30:09+00:00
simple-description (llama3.2-vision_11b)
This meme is a humorous representation of the world's history of exploration and cartography. It's a map from the 17th century, featuring a fantastical and inaccurate depiction of the world, with mythical creatures and exaggerated geography. The text at the top reads "A New Map of the Terraqueous Globe according to the Ancients", highlighting the era's understanding of the world's geography.
detailed-analysis (gemma3-27b-vision)
Okay, let's break down this 17th-century map of the world, titled "A New Map of the Terraqueous Globe," through several analytical lenses. I will provide sections based on which analytical frameworks are most applicable to understanding this image. (Some may be brief, or omitted if not relevant).
1. Visual Description
The image is a large, double-hemisphere world map rendered in a style typical of the early 17th century. It's a copperplate engraving, hand-colored with a somewhat muted palette dominated by ochre, beige, and faded blues. The map is highly ornamental and heavily layered with text.
* Map Projection: The map uses a double-hemisphere projection, effectively a split view of the world. This projection style prioritizes showing the entirety of the Earth, but distorts area and shape.
* Continental Shapes: Continents are depicted with a degree of inaccuracy, showing a limited understanding of the Americas and a significant "terra incognita" (unknown land) in areas like Australia and parts of Africa and Asia. The Americas are surprisingly well-defined for the period, but still with inaccuracies.
* Ornamentation: The map is filled with intricate decorative elements. These include ornate cartouches (decorative frames) containing text, sea monsters, sailing ships, wind faces, and allegorical figures. These aren't merely decorative; they often carry symbolic meaning.
* Text & Language: A substantial amount of text is present, labeling continents, regions, and providing explanatory notes. The map is in English, reflecting its intended audience.
* Allegorical Figures: Above and below the hemispheres are allegorical figures representing the various continents and winds. These figures are in classical style, referencing Greco-Roman mythology and traditions. These figures suggest that the mapmaker seeks to establish a sense of authority and cultural superiority.
2. Foucauldian Genealogical Discourse Analysis
This map is an excellent example for a Foucauldian analysis because it illustrates how “truth” is constructed through discourse and power relations.
Power/Knowledge: The map is not a neutral representation of the world. It’s a production of knowledge inextricably linked to the power of European exploration and colonialism. The very act of mapping is an assertion of control—claiming ownership over space by naming and defining it. The map creates* the world it depicts, rather than simply reflecting it.
* Discursive Formations: The map reveals a specific “discursive formation” – a system of thought, language, and practices that constructs the world in a certain way. Here, the discourse is one of European centrality. Europe is placed in a prominent position, and the map’s perspective assumes a European point of view. The "terra incognita" areas demonstrate the limits of this discourse, but also its ambition to extend that knowledge and control to the entire globe.
* Genealogical Approach: Looking at the history of mapmaking reveals how these representations have evolved over time. Earlier maps were often based on myth and religious beliefs. This map, while still containing elements of allegory, represents a shift towards empirical observation (though still heavily biased). Tracing the genealogy of cartography shows how knowledge has been produced, contested, and transformed.
* Subjectivation: The map plays a role in "subjectivation"—how individuals are constructed as subjects within a particular power/knowledge system. By presenting a European-centric view of the world, the map reinforces a specific identity and sense of place for Europeans. It also positions non-European peoples as "other" and often as objects of exploration and control.
3. Critical Theory
The map lends itself to a Critical Theory analysis, particularly considering its relationship to Enlightenment thought and the rise of imperialism.
* Hegemony: The map can be interpreted as a tool of cultural hegemony. By constructing a particular image of the world, it normalizes European dominance and obscures the perspectives of colonized peoples. The map is not just a description of the world; it’s a justification for European expansion and control.
* Enlightenment Project & Its Shadows: The map reflects the Enlightenment emphasis on reason and empirical observation, yet it simultaneously embodies the darker side of the Enlightenment – its complicity with colonialism and the exploitation of non-European cultures. The map embodies a desire for universal knowledge, but this desire is ultimately linked to a desire for power and control.
Representation & Ideology: The map isn’t a neutral representation of the world; it’s a constructed* representation that embodies specific ideological assumptions. The emphasis on European geography and the depiction of non-European lands as “unknown” or “savage” reflect a hierarchical worldview. The use of classical allegory reinforces the idea of European cultural superiority.
4. Marxist Conflict Theory
From a Marxist perspective, the map is deeply tied to the historical development of capitalism and the expansion of European economic power.
* Resource Control: The map can be seen as a visual representation of the drive to control resources and establish trade routes. The exploration and mapping of the world were driven by a desire to find new sources of raw materials, markets for manufactured goods, and opportunities for investment.
* Imperialism & Exploitation: The map is a product of, and a tool for, European imperialism. The mapping of territories facilitated colonial expansion and the exploitation of labor and resources in colonized lands. The map highlights the power imbalances between Europe and the rest of the world.
* Class Relations & Colonialism: The wealth generated by colonial ventures benefited European elites, while the majority of the world’s population suffered under colonial rule. The map obscures these class relations by presenting a simplified and idealized picture of the world.
In conclusion, this 17th-century map is much more than a geographical representation. It is a powerful cultural artifact that reveals a great deal about the power relations, ideologies, and historical forces that shaped the early modern world. Through various critical lenses, we can uncover the complex and often problematic ways in which knowledge is constructed and used to legitimize domination.
simple-description (llama3.2-vision)
This meme is an image of an old world map, specifically the 1700s-era "A New Map of the Terraqueous Globe" by John Senex. The image features two large globes, one showing the Eastern Hemisphere and the other showing the Western Hemisphere. The text at the top of the image reads "A New Map of the Terraqueous Globe according to the Ancient Discoveries and most general Divisions of it into Continents and Oceans".
tesseract-ocr
Gl OBE according R 2 |: OU d OCEANS Ti CONTINENTS an SLES: he it into — , ' 1 fj S O SSS SS == «a SS —- d molt pee a = ee 2 SS Se gles gest . 26 SS oS sg . SS ct t Dilcoveries = SSS SSS SS — ££f = _ 2 = SS Ol 11 2 ole = ——— = = ow a Late aes N= = = lg ZO AY Le x é x \ S =a a - Sse if Ly a NSE = —= Ie oS, Y aioe! f mw ° XC es = a °° see oN, as oe Cen 4, ‘On Ui WK Re SS oo iy LEGS 4 en / ey, Pe) gs i / ~~ i X = =. NOGELE Fane WV ss 2S CY, Ha & a | a | = ” 2 ie tes Ye _—/ “0. Sy h, Sr 1 ia ° \ eee CO fo c> een aad | ie ew A sé LU ON aa YS ey lL Ge Lark / Borne wee \ = by Ly BAG, OE se Se 2h 4 CTE ROP, pt wi A . =£C. Sf es ey a fhe advininglly RAS : ed NON O ~ Sint pS a ‘\ gs mS \ OK ss “a. ep. : Vlad f generally ) se Gas ~ Wy L WS SS Syn PO a | (Contmens- ee Ss , — é/ Son A ~Oy,/ Sp ofedt 0 have beens | 4 yp 4 BS F* ‘ Yi 7 x & S =. x Je 8 ay 3 | bi. Wh ae “\ oo H TY & jy / Z Mictently re re net 122 \ they \ WAYS a Lg NDI |Z, 2 t Ts ce 7 Vitieg ReUigh there: are will have Pe di Yona eo SS Lipya oP & J 3 : wot => % He MF Re ting fome, who al to be % ZO \ V% a y AY live e Sa ! ae (ed : A Ts oy Pace PU \ontinent its feof Infula NW AS SS Lg ¥ ; ie Ti’ y 2 =F PF Coa, Al 1 He oes AFRICANS a's eee i 72 ye QIN ATLAN' ae Lage a 278 VAY te ey _ <) f RA Oh de Saf ND ay Nl Cet ad Js wey Ancients. Qa ae ae OE s uN K Me each 4 9 Continens}, s ve a2 AE) = Pik ol Ele Sele ley N Aaquinlocatil a 2p, “a | 3 oo ae eat We ase ArH ors J, eta a Me): ‘ Sey / DEAE a = c y Leeeoee ts 4 Se OS sc -. E | 4. eee Ba oe — ox -| Im co SAF pes lng ~C eee ae Ea 6 Be AS Sea sy } | i Ly 2 inc “| ne eo a |e Re 767 fm \ 8 Se. {9 ee | “oo* é NSOLILI. Ne a _ yee] e a AT £ IE RE : at | ee = sr rte a s fy , eS __ oR : |, nass,| § fg ae o \o eS ey el Se 4 53 | | er a! } ¥ f /E od es Is . lg Sea eR Aa al ie borat Ce tae Sy y | pris rr aris. > : Mf S Yip mo Es TORRID ZONE Se eT eles of ee o_ ans ‘iz ed Slo Sipe alisha ENB In this New Sete of Maps for the better Diftinceiny Ad = 8 ‘ eee = eles ee {i2o / a E: | f Circulus “Scapegoat hi Siike tf Pie the Earth hun lp BY ? ao ' > : TS es a eS ge se between the etter a jt ere Ancionaly AY S S KT Ff. | f ee Ve acuiioatiilis. lymg #5 | Lrown have the, Ba & eng raven 7 | = ec J = oo {so Teenie enrse mrs. | Yictoc a iow etal IN wo at Vy oe ts A aE L-¢ [eas aa] tty ring Reni tees 4 i \ Sgn be ie Re [ze 2 \ : a2 2 Doe SF” Ro io 4 = ey are Ovs\ces she ae ‘ ES siti, ff A\ \ & fe = t y 9 to Mone, rl ZONE a E Yi, y fas \\ B le ~ es Nal oe pEMPERA & a A fe \ ¥% = =| 20% HE wick: of Cap 2 /; A eX \ C A a = = e ree Laney a free FN \ \ x K 2 Oe ee, * A a : — SS oY ws oS a Bee Lae SG ae se SN S \ cS x SF Ze 8 = SAN FP geanre Ey A kA . {Ly ag ee 2 = © jee Peak S os Ot oo Nie sh —- =X » Ora ra Mi 7X» S au) we i Ky CS EN Pe / Ww ZZ a j (a Fa EN > Ore avert ig 7g) <\ JS a as a Ee Dy) i ee es. SSS 4 —— = eS >. A Seat age ve \ c* oe A ae te oo Te oe ne BSc aa Zs ee eo a a es oi — eS - os a, near cea oan Lee TS his Hiphinef aN rer cl Site oe. L) —-.../ a oS Sg be 3. @ Oe We ea ee IAM GES ee\ a a WE SEZs Oeics ae = a) Se Ny og oN Go) Site yg {Duke of Glo aie NEST ee a pe _— yh i ve 2 oe Fe fi ee t—O : iy a, Me P| Pe 7 eee | \exs wa i Sor, ; ; : a a ee I 2 ed a ORS dy rerronen le ee = ACCOR | SS eee ee Sr ae ee TOR TS: a SS ee = ae 3 wa a 2 = ee Er a x a LS - sun eee Se (gee a ee rs Fr siris ett eee Sa 2 2S aa Lek nae LAE ES OTE TR