First Seen
2015-12-18T09:30:09+00:00
simple-description (llama3.2-vision_11b)
This meme is an old map of Europe, specifically the "Carte de l'Europe" by Guillaume Dufour, published in 1789. The image appears to be a hand-drawn illustration of the European continent, with various countries and regions labeled. The text at the top of the image reads "Carte de l'Europe" and "Dedie a Monseigneur le Comte de la Vigne".
detailed-analysis (gemma3-27b-vision)
Okay, let's break down this 17th/18th century map of Europe through several theoretical lenses. It’s rich in detail, making it ideal for complex analysis.
## Visual Description
The image is a richly colored, antique map of Europe, likely dating from the late 17th or early 18th century given its style. It is rendered in pastel hues of yellow, green, pink and blue, and features intricately detailed borders, topography (mountains depicted as miniature ranges), and city names. The map is decorated with elaborate cartouches – ornate frames containing titles and illustrations. In the upper left is a cartouche with the map's title and attribution. Decorative figures, including cherubs or allegorical representations, are also included. The geographical areas are defined by boundaries drawn in a variety of colors. The map portrays a Europe of shifting kingdoms and empires, with borders different from those of today. The oceans surrounding Europe are labeled in Latin: Oceanus Septentrionalis (Northern Ocean), Oceanus Atlanticus (Atlantic Ocean) and the Mediterranean is shown. Topographical details are present, indicated by shaded areas showing mountain ranges, and small representations of forests. The level of detail suggests this was a product of considerable surveying and scholarly work, intended for a well-educated audience.
## Foucauldian Genealogical Discourse Analysis
This map isn’t just a “representation” of Europe, but a discourse that actively constructs Europe. Using a Foucauldian approach, we can examine how this map produces knowledge about Europe and establishes regimes of truth.
Power/Knowledge: The map isn't a neutral depiction, but an exercise of power. The act of mapping itself is a way of claiming, classifying, and controlling space. The map-maker, supported by the political, economic, and cultural forces of the time, defines* what constitutes Europe, its boundaries, and its internal organization. The level of detail devoted to certain regions versus others reveals priorities and power dynamics. For example, areas under the influence of the map’s patron (likely a royal court) would be more meticulously mapped than less important or controlled areas.
Discursive Formations: The way the map categorizes regions (kingdoms, duchies, empires) establishes a discourse of political legitimacy. The map doesn't simply reflect existing political structures; it reinforces and solidifies them. The visual boundaries perform* the act of creating nations, even if those nations were fluid or contested in reality.
* Genealogy of Order: Examining the evolution of maps over time reveals shifts in power dynamics, knowledge production, and the conceptualization of Europe. Comparing this map to earlier or later ones would expose how the “truth” about Europe was constantly negotiated and re-defined. The map’s aesthetic style (ornate, classical) suggests a desire to connect contemporary Europe with a perceived glorious past, justifying existing power structures through a constructed historical narrative.
## Critical Theory (Frankfurt School)
Applying Critical Theory, particularly drawing from the Frankfurt School, highlights the map's role in upholding and naturalizing structures of domination.
* Instrumental Reason: The map exemplifies the triumph of instrumental reason – the focus on efficiency, classification, and control. It reduces the complex, lived realities of Europe to quantifiable and categorizable units. This process, while appearing objective, masks underlying power relations and suppresses alternative ways of knowing and experiencing the continent.
* Enlightenment & Domination: The map’s attempt to rationally classify and represent Europe can be seen as a manifestation of Enlightenment ideals. However, the Frankfurt School critiques the Enlightenment as contributing to a form of “instrumental reason” that ultimately serves to dominate and control. The map, as a tool of rationalization, contributes to this process by imposing a fixed, objective gaze on the continent, potentially legitimizing colonialism and empire.
* Mass Culture & Standardization: While not directly a product of “mass culture” in the modern sense, the map represents a desire to standardize knowledge and create a unified, coherent image of Europe. This act of standardization can be seen as a precursor to the homogenizing tendencies of mass culture, suppressing regional diversity and alternative perspectives.
## Marxist Conflict Theory
From a Marxist perspective, this map reveals the material forces shaping Europe and the inherent conflicts within its geopolitical landscape.
* Mode of Production & Territorial Control: The map illustrates the struggle for territorial control over resources and trade routes. The meticulously defined borders represent the boundaries of different modes of production (feudalism, early capitalism, etc.) and the conflicts between them. Areas with dense urban centers and developed infrastructure likely represent centers of economic power.
* Class Struggle & Regional Disparities: The level of detail devoted to certain regions might reflect their economic importance and the presence of a powerful ruling class. Regions that are less detailed or depicted as “wild” might represent areas of peasant rebellion or resistance to central authority.
* Imperialism & Colonial Expansion: While the map primarily focuses on Europe, it can also be interpreted as a tool for justifying or planning colonial expansion. The detailed knowledge of European geography and resources would have been valuable for military campaigns and trade ventures. The map thus becomes implicated in the exploitation of resources and people in other parts of the world.
## Postmodernism
A postmodern analysis would question the very idea of a “true” or “objective” representation of Europe.
* Deconstruction of “Europe”: The map’s depiction of Europe as a unified entity can be deconstructed. “Europe” is not a natural or pre-given category, but a socially constructed concept that changes over time. The map’s borders are arbitrary and contingent, reflecting the interests of the map-maker rather than any inherent geographical or cultural reality.
* Simulation & Hyperreality: The map can be seen as a “simulation” of Europe, a representation that becomes more real than the reality it supposedly represents. It creates a “hyperreality” in which the map’s image of Europe becomes the dominant way of understanding the continent.
* Loss of Grand Narratives: The map’s attempt to create a coherent narrative of Europe can be challenged. Postmodernism rejects “grand narratives” (like the idea of a unified European identity) and emphasizes the fragmentation, complexity, and contingency of reality.
## Queer Feminist Intersectional Analysis
Applying a Queer Feminist Intersectional lens, we can scrutinize how the map silences or marginalizes certain groups and reinforces patriarchal and colonial power structures.
* Silencing of Indigenous/Non-State Groups: The map prioritizes the boundaries of states and kingdoms, effectively erasing the presence and agency of Indigenous peoples, nomadic groups, and other non-state actors. It reinforces a colonial logic that privileges state power over other forms of social organization.
* Patriarchal Cartography: The map's very act of “claiming” and “mapping” territory is historically linked to patriarchal control over land and resources. The map maker and the audience it catered to were largely male. This influences what is mapped, how it is mapped, and whose perspectives are prioritized.
* Gendered Spaces & Exclusion: The map does not represent social relationships, gender roles, or the experiences of marginalized groups. It constructs a largely homogenous and masculine image of Europe, ignoring the diversity of gender identities, sexualities, and experiences.
* Intersectionality: The map's depiction of Europe must be analyzed through an intersectional lens. The erasure of Indigenous, non-state, and marginalized groups is not simply a matter of geography, but a result of the intersecting systems of power – colonialism, patriarchy, classism, and racism.
Disclaimer: These analyses are interpretations based on the visual information provided. A more thorough analysis would require historical context and further research.
simple-description (llama3.2-vision)
This meme is a picture of a map of the world, but with the borders of Europe and the Middle East removed, leaving a large "hole" in the center. The text "I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right" appears in the top left corner. The meme is likely being used to express a sense of confidence or superiority in a conversation or debate.
tesseract-ocr
| SR Se ae Se aN ay Pose ee oy, ie “pete Se fe pe pe 4 oR aes : : hes Sa oe 8 as Se a Se ee he 1s fos Seb we eel co S Ele Oe Nae ee ee re 13] é i EW T|R I . SSE re ee ne iS) 2 Sty Pe ef i wt On AS roL\. oi se og ee was j | aa: o 4 Bag Re VGN SY ott” ‘ : ‘S » . Ss oS = of 2 f oF ope a FP Ses ager é te) TE xa ¢ : Stag A Ray, : =. ae VS fase = é Cider. Ne SO Se Ba eee pieeed fi : ing RT he a i 3 Be 7 9 ios Ne ) 5 ee we ~, i, Ee ae SF Ba ec, eters 4 Sy pitts DIY 0 | noe ah 5° ‘ ZB YO Qe ey See On ips = Sie. a eae shahott eo sae eee" i x : ob fh BOS ee Usrapet eK AIS | 8 aye mee ST (2 Faye : - Se FR ee See Ny odie wae ee fe LIND a RP A eo fee IS ie Ese ae a aaflirloy Bt. = Lees Sf eae i ate r Oe) Fey \ “a Bed at eat go cot \ ge eos ra ey ee seme | Eley ee Bafa eae Ry selee Nd . Fi, Sos aa wy oe eed VEE ee ot 4 Ciicatheg Spm ge eee ans ug Te oly hea = = STE : = ha. ee = : 2 eg OM. ot 8 pig t Fe Bed Fax, 3} ake relpenes Joy > RTT geht 2 ae 3 ALS 2 ee Sta TA cushuaa geared K IC WD fo ae ee ee Fe eprae Ys pas 0 A ot, gga Spek aoe = FHP ee AS See F halt pete sil a aes fa a PAE fA eee meer oT co Fae 0%, ane a Sete Ausra Nera SO) pT IIMA Re eA <a Fs > es iat sé re ae ofl Ce ei x Es i a sate. 3 : y MMeaye Cebrarae Ni Z ee 4 BS Oo eee GS) mae Seah Ee Pate ER Ges ee oe eet L Re her = Liga. eee: mgt SoS (sicher SQ er. Fs ap sf SIG ee 3 Sea ae tie ae : F. B aa tox Mires (2 BS |S Ee AY pos a off" Spee tie | Pe BEN Fe onc note FLAP pao HEAT OR cor Se BEER Cocke Bove ee er Gee eee ee eZ Lie a Se ek ee nein ee Nees BON Ser oxk es Sage ees ep Las gat Rice 2 GNP Mess! A | See le 3 . ek. FS ns ta VOONY c Peay wae. pe tbe = oA se tia Par ee eT ro atl Z Gage \o. 8 ick Fag S Ppt et a i Ee == — = 2 aaa ~ Soe 3 = at eu! a ba re BPoltrch Sy ee ey eS ‘Ss ee es AS . Thaa* te Loe gh Spee || S || one a ee 9 peor ys pga PN Waa ca Eee See ee eee eee a ot met” NE PS Bs SP ||| Sj eas EE DL ee Cc An, Tine LO eR Ne tba a Kesey ap Spee ee ei GULEP ONE AYE ee Ne eu Keepfne Oa =) 3 Se iS SQ el! ZS ere & ctcus om CA hoe Sp rae S77 (jo ST LA Det a Nera we pe * * eS Bie ee Oe é a Wee! ye SS Ege’ 4 Ve, Meee Pee Re fase \ ets f f) eee ats f I ee eed oN a ge e nia YS case | Pew, Kccuratillime 4) Hee mee Uo N | % Lig, pee EA SET pr atle ee fh Pi ie Sef Bre, Set Nac tyes TNE iS an. Be Mill | (ol See =) | ee Spe ec ee beer. Ly F : Fike. Oe pes: Foe st X fork SR eas F a SSeS 3 see EUROPA Y Eee Afr UGK ee BREN CN Sane oh Se ee oe ss uy as.) Ae BS atten. % QUES 5 me yy Bie nape ag nie RE : eee ste open ei a Ebates ee ~ ete 8 (ee eee pS hey 5 Tr ABULA, Oe ig En a Se SSR Scuy wre. S Rona a \ ores Ra OK ey Secstay [Teather el, agen os: cane Yehh § | aie aces correcta \y ger is = O a RABE au 8 i E eae Nett wont PN as MAE ust pi SiN pose 20, 0 4 EP me & JES Se5 a Heperrime edica yy - Wey a ia Ny - ey eee eS. RSS A SMe aan ay eo ee ioe 2508 Bax RU™ Za ose D ately Neen ote RG PS lem ae [| = & | GAUTHORE (ee re ee Farovlatel U — 2b ieee gee TT ee ae Be et iy reer See, SIME eee ts MeL ae © a Beg OY Siegel] ; | am CAR 4 2 fae = S ewe Sg x A ope SS Se | gaan eee ee gk ay ae fF \ EGO on = ee ne AP Me wp Be ell 2 a ROLO ALLARD, fj. = ae wef oe et pe eg ee eee | NO Sree ee So cee | A po te Ree, \ ¥ SS I ee oo} es ae |S ip a> Ee Be wee = ae Y are seers LIne ly Seas SE eee Lh PBs Ge ase ie a bee ee \ Lot Gets Sade 34 | PT dae ON oo i oe Pe ee re EE Re PBR ar tena mea oT \, MRR ESE el? ilies PRs tee) arses Site, Hi yadradet : Pay Ca py Ns ey Pe ee OSS 5 SSS oe Se Ses OF is: TEEN ER io. oR HALE CREE ee en ung Ea ce See da 2 Ena BBA | ls : WS . "es aT eee a, ie = Fea ne =} oy wale spat bos See a ee o>} “ eth SO eee A Eee whan (gee arriba % x 9th P Ser tA G q a . die 2h ey b a St = a. SAE er gan eget se Bs 3 “2 ee = ea 7S a . = Sta ast OS oad © Sidilges pest Me 9 2.8 BS > = — a A ey £2 oa: Int Schetland ee SURES Pas ! BR Sore aierh BID. [te See ra. So Ni feria, oy Rae BF Sa PE ee se eee a » \ Reged My G = a, E Lees 2 = Ese iland atHitland 29) ay 28 BATE 3G them (nis Gi ter QS Se erro et Renee SERS ane 1 Rea Sat, Fae a ae are Eas oe el we. WPA Le oo ae ox soccer | TPAC Wn sf RNS, ieee | agen eh TY fo Bree Ra ANTES BE Se see, xa Lge aia He i= fi lA =e ‘ ays === AEE] rn 3 eS ae ale] Rs). hee. cee Go apes, a co I phe a ea. re = ee eat sls, alt 7 Z,, Lee a SS eee 8 ae (peg eee | tcialen. 9p Ee oe fe se Feeley eee oe 2) SSR Rear is Soe eee Se SN eee Sk A Re al ep Fh Se CRs ‘e at MS | 3 =a ee Ve ee | eee =a ne Siler BG (8 WIP cae tr xo eri a ey ee Sen oA ros ot Ne ee 2h att as PAL ey Pee ra BY 8A SOF ete ether 25 2] iz Peay e.. (a a SS Se = On ENDS NGAS Wy Ree dee cal bean eA Eine YS ee ee oe tT eet Tih oeRerimgea DUB SRLS \ 9 Sifiske pe te ene) fprrotek A) | | 2 eSak Sel et = Ss eben. a, = ae eee ON DES IS a Fite pee Fi ee N Be Me et Re, Le, Be Serine hg BAER ALS see qe tgete& i Ss =a Ween: |= A: Siena | S522 Si dd wen eee SE Be ee i gaark BS CAR ee Y Bar | Sue * EAU 95 ‘ hes AE Mg aoe NE: Pegs Van spate ele eke age eas gt Seek as Ee AS \ pws pe ae ce in ae SES < cea REP Ae DM ar PRS OEE | Bel vayhcie ey FAN fa. es eee we ae me gee \ ated § Ghinae (ac ee + aul ON memes So" Z So {oS aS ee a iter dei ad a Siren BS | cokes ae) a am tae aati shy a eee Z ety Be utes Sees” Reece t Sine gir BY J]? | sie ia e se Se eee ae = yaa. Z rl RR Pde fx Mh res are 2 ie § ay POR Se ae te ee stems LAG Sp Ra Vp Oy ees foe Rees alge oe Sores BS ee = Se ae hw thle AS > Bee Zpiem BES Dag sty SA sy ig Teton, Sa AS pale Dh ‘ae Ditevess | Rotiaen 43 E [eal Se ee PRS a Jae co 2 2. Seed i Pe aE. eee eG Dua Yap cfg ape fr eatoein yo Ge Cader ae Wales Sree, Ds \ He hee Pie ee aa a i == a ne { fe? Bete SN aes ee iF Woe ix, ss jeezy) ioe és i ud Aas Cnn als x -— erg otis if XY Oro spar, _ “f . “leg Sera. ante pe, PO, ie = ( Se pe PS MOP a? ee 7 as, SES Te Nal eA 2p teks. Sak Seog mS ace ee 6 "gt i> (ae a =< ed. 223 3 _ ‘Ma eer Eee a pee ee tS Se Sag a ee BAN ies ed a chyeeed oes ap\ea ieee Pi rib N ece\ of ds ~ ise - itn ne —_———— jit gee oe ge a5 ee eS ae Sas pe re es eS ee paar eke kh Bettce ee az @ Se a IO Sehenkzen Be Pics y fet gue Us ee uu A Se a or Sipe RE MH er) oes Se eS BM sis Se ade Bet tonto ss eg Re A eg. IE ee, B eS pee YE < = eS. 2 PIR A eae — dee 228s Pe es ee = | aes alt JNA Jacke Akos = Meena i eee Eads AES Lan, igs ibe aa == = Ss —— a Pie (Go te = ei is hee, eae Q ee ed et Beko Ir a ee ee Dien Poa J 8, traieey de SBD peuisst pen oe \~ ieee as je F = = eS Ee ee ot fe ei =s | ee ee mee ig Dae Syod feeetl, ep ern a Bhech ree (eee Oe, RE sn She Bete ACN Seeds Die ae “ae BS C= ae ee bagels, Do ae R ngage Ae a cae TR ON BRA Ee ee gaps AEE 8» oO Ie BEET OL taken GR” Sige Nacoaver™ © len - : { 3 —S—S Se SS OT ici ip ae Bae. fats lig. Ma Pe! Re attw er SER OT ENG oz a GatBeageate ee ae Grae. Pei i pantie | a8 PE @ Pafkses YON Ve roRvor =k oly © ae. os 35 | be y = tie ee 4 it SDs eee geek N Tote Vile Schag Mayo a Sons q s Selo Ry ee eer Be BER eects Ay hee Z\, . Broudaf (22 See gle Riese A = NS Salfir three la | 4 a ee ee ea or bad Bee Iculy foaey eg. Bornes Mee pe B- & ani Be - pen ase! = a ee ee se 4. Vote Nees Eee Kas << 2) 5 se se Ee ae TT 6 Bo Ag ae SRS er ee ae SoU oth, ae atte o8 ae Reactant Ss ; ds i y = Bee oh ae, a Fe cua y, eet’ 2 eee scr ae aegis O sa Le cei eae ¢ Aas Nee. 2 ee, VF bi casts ET ee agen bi eee ke set at ssi PA \ sts 3 \oq - Teh lma IEE, aoe fe. ee ‘stile ule og re aa bet clase et. ig aE toe 50 iia Sere Dx Vea ee Rien ee SG aie: She eK a's Wh J yy flr RE aes PSEA ee ey = = Fae. ap eon ei, gv mated wee SO8 pep co, en, Ege cancer a Ne pme tipster os re EFS : = a See See ge 6. (32 D men A ae ee is Re OR eens hs Feaceve Seed Tare cite = PN gee CR att Se Fae Rie Bee att SA S| Eo ¥ sy, <i ad Fi cog Tiber ais Be St Menten” OO ee ee ie Ene a Sin Gh gf Yt BA & Se Sige Re Sfenoer Maen ers SEN Bigs eo Set Ae ee Satie BS | = >; ea lin) OP se sete aR tee Sok ae RDS Solel a Tere i iS S 2 poate em eae Biter shoal Peckte oes opee eae we scowl Ae ware re eee cig oe Se ea PB [Sop & 5 i Gee eS ee | i Ee a rs regs en ER wate, ee teed ae <a pee yatye™ BF et hhc Fiske es 9 OEE ase. (|S Sif spurs So OP fe cumagt ee oh Rink fe gd eR re ee Mare BM Py ae Fa hast P erent Eas ee as SD ae by Bimies m ht Creme ae Bote REEL ee ae Oyl| ° By a AS a ae [ | 2a ae ln op Foner wf eg (hae ofa co irs evel ta i Slay tee rs be te Ea teh oy pen “RES Be ae ay ae PAR | i By fr ae hoe Tipit a ae tn eS Sef Ee Tuga att BR Sey ee CU a | BAe 4 aa ENG oat! Catone eT nl RE SANTA Tighe \ ‘Babe PO gtte gee hy pas) ws Ce at Sa, ope Der Sah tna) eh 8, Bete Ele Ee , ae me ee “ae ee ee Biante it eae ReY BEEPS FE, be ee Vz reer fete Shia, ess fittesiy «Big eT P45" 5, VO... Zrescouar GL Bi * } “ en eS cath 4 = pee, 0, pl LS Fel Sede oe oan gee St nae EE PG Saath d Sek AS \ ren gg td, eather Cle Shee PE areas A atehe rsh Betarck WE Ge Bl | gent BS ieecces cba F om = by SS ee Pore o Rack Ach thane Spee a = Bs Nh sa a Meeauces , gkeatlt RARER 5. Fe Rt orsiae Be pps cent |e gf = s e 3 BS le li R} ead. Beene, spite =e Ciel [een Pa Sais gene he SE Bett Peete at Caer ae ante Cages Tee sreeton ee ee Ne [ae a a wee) is if — ee. AOE AG ea) Rage Boss SAC JE SRG etch. Pha* YC ae TEN oe | Map h oe sis “ x ay eee AS GN Bed egea nae Fe 8c marv ate, Yt oh pceesh Bares = 2 ee ist 4 o til cpa <r Be eam Re) ack ee as pear Moc GR tad Mer, tt BSR aha Vad ee. ee ee ree na We Ves SE\ A Le \ FTE le F e = ae ot Bin Ee, A as RC Aes ea sate PY xin LES fe ie Sep SE er Nes ere pas yar enone ets Nn | 0. (yee Hite ee calntebea te, dino of E BS ere elt omraee EE ee ier: Crensdean apgll dase, Gere tes f Ma eenliy fea acer ee pee ke ee agen Nee i JP es) 1), Soest hoes ¥ fro Fog 2, Neat qt SS %, \ tae ey py 2 H Ay state A 8 Meee ace ESR ae je Et ee ey cary ae Ss Ms jen Bie ditlas oP ieee ete ee GS Na Deora Pea Hot TEU (ila Dona s tig te gh fa,\. = oz. egice tee =| led 0. ees ADEE cae ees We Sta eta 4 a thas trey a) ee eR Re eet Be (Qe mntets ateuttnge (EE Go ot wee 8 i? F © H Palen geese yr ae See eres, Srhitad tat Ea ee ee CER ae Cee AE Sct Rae S| eam ariene re Fo CON on Sel Sasewyfensnt x Wee \oateeeey ie eet Ser Wie. Ba Z} \y Ss ig £ wR cos bates. Mavexe Rela ttanasl [aia Seale NSS Se on peo see ee he Se Eve 1) Spe hity hese Sg iene OR ety Ne SE coset atte ah fhe Seen | eats ae ia shag NS eer IS dg oe Serer aay ROG > ee geen errs Oa 0, ten Oy Bay NAT Po tiem Lam Nar Esra ARNT din a Seeker es, EEE 6, sla VER yielery 3 see Mira | \~ CS es RB tS ee sole Seay ete Rg Or Pe no a ees fare a ad ka EI a8 i OE en, ON ie POI SS,,.. a if ae EN Pear pees BN Pisa RSs Mas ee a Be eGAS NV a ee aay ee ra So eR Sta re as St fo EE ee Sa Pop iON ref ° 1b Oy ES ae ee ep ake | ee oe Bea i Mira Bo fing ee, De ye z peaks | Cy Pte GN irre nr age Cie 6 LE Salt Pit dk Sele NTS eq <q 2 Sie ene BS PIL eee iia es ohn UL ee Spgency ¢ pas Nee Te ee See ae Deas NN See 2G ee, Mote Mulce V sng? wap te \o 2g weg Fg We rk oS ee ence on Nee ee ers Bi Enel tags PRN al st ae A eS ie, as paws} io BRU acplen Vey epi ee ce SE arth? Prrsecxty. ss Bites 3 ca a a) = see ehh Marsh 75 Be Saiey oats aeeinalne ie ea a oe eee cee NE Se Romoge Oat nbtnlogs R83 aeage Wee R LS Ge * Wie eect Zrldes oe f pasate is Be eter ee fe ea re ORs aes (Se Lato tele yep ET GE Megtoteer a ge Ho ary eer a ae Dees foe a elias ee a A &y 0 ae LA ae TNE a Aaa ie mtoge cee Ve tes (Zifor «ks MAS Fanci ni pene DP Se ccs cA go New fy ae get EN. cant 3 ay ve ticte, Hh 8 q Eile ae rea in So mermeneky Vest a NE eB UIES ba) pt Nekoi if eatet Mer Te se Se PR ov" Sarg Seboron Rh eg te Sere" othe _ fi ae tie Toe aes eo we ky Be 4 ee ie ee ea oss co te a eee Gor Re, Sa apne nea 5 Brats “=e anata ce ke. ey Peed oe se oy eke © fee a *2 eet ANN os duet ph oa of Pectin ae ee es ee & Bh Ee Donic ete | come oll, if Res ese ceeee SAY Ee rma we s ue 8 ce) te eP oe t E ate tet okt Loy ete Pernt Fl Gras NS ee ty ay" Daicoion pareecs fe Beecoye Aa Ee rae See Disie Seta pe types pe Se 3 sie Seen Te |Sq Cte Oreymad by) cemleeeereee se CSD a, erie: Sf Beit eens oe finn ty BL Erase setae, bas pleat caf aes pte RaPokuria serie yee ay ee i hae 2 SG OS eee ee «& = [ ei Hos Pee | GED RN ott Biel No ae ONE NG lin pai pe a gare S| gee pee eee Wf A fl & f Ca inch reagan sores Grn Ratna Baa ee Fife ee alae at eae cae Feet Do ec Creag awn (ot BN Games eee pee Uc tas ii gl ie tuiss J ot \ EP 4, eS sen ‘ ee a rae Odd te eee TE eh DP cge ret Aes 8) paar a ae B Grassi? a : a je mir Se ee | ae Ln \\ he SS 2 : ts SIS a % | Ry} Y cca BOE et he pen sn, aot tN eae Gh) See ENC. re Eee Sete IN Se Hie ANS EMS trdyn We to tN St atc ahead ees eee i soe’ x3 aw) ahi oN se rae E is By E oe es ‘ ears mae ies = ae eR eS ee ee fae Ete Meo ze Se Safa Oe as gama Senay ite Saas ore ae Reed pte LN Bins 5 (ARABEA fr & =: Caer Bo remfruck pete SAS icon oF oe) Filf3| SG rents Thdesah® ce oe tf St 3 Sarre TY BN coe Lei, seal gl ae Errand Se See FO er ete ie Cairo WA? ah oe sie redo imal “| 5 pen ee Seg ee Bo gill | Be, ee Dees ig os Hee se See Ss ee eee Guns acpi ats Peg Se Se rie SIE ete) Ne eee et Ne ae ae wah) RN Rae perl aC tors oye Bae Bee ab ig ee | isk _ BoM oh nor Pp Aia Rte Be fae 5 Steep ate Se oes fon Rte y(t. ea ed Sonal aes keys, SO NS ehh aid AE AS te A gay TN Tae ae a aaa Page, Gate = \ AS | 2 2 oe ee Bris bee Fran eRe Ps err! Sg Fon, DAL Cyaan aR og ("SEES aE SRS Es tae ead | ATR FoF | Bate ee ae 3 5 ; : ig jO a gee PE Peat Pe Sa Pega aor tee a eas SS i Sige ead SY Wt so fete s Jato gees, Tet Be ae fae ee he eee eS Seb ee asta i: iS as i Gna e eh sere * Meee Se asd tan 8 Kat teed bee) Crean Bh a a WS Ke fear mee | ene sa LETS age Se Tes et eats | BO * re b \ee x ae prt a Befactinese Ghee ih = es ed dle Ae SEBS os I S eontenn SLE utter fhi ge esee CONE, SAS ae = ee eae Kash Bs aE c Be ae IME Ay goon ke ee e Art ge re ie tI MM afpeh "Oa Le Cede Bp etapa Lae EOE EE Pat f ateonee Dahan patio = = 2s eae. Z ng aloe a, canton a ae Z =e ag iva A A \xoB lal raf ne EPO ‘a ea tS Boy ae aoe Gehatec at kag . Sea a Ae PIAS aphobecs on Bs fein Pn DE Pie ~ SE Ea lz else? Se ice St Ragen. 9 Cansobils. ‘ |" 8 f SB efee Ce es Be feo Bt che eee waste) shag Tage ae BES a Le pee G Toe” Ah a ores re Ia oO & 82 a 44eew = \ S Pca re ee y lef ote Foe Ci ne PAA Eee fe,” 5 ete es Ras gee Ng ea ee tc Sgt ag MO MS Bae Sey eet Ps. igi? ee ees ee S| SE Bay | Brey ES SoSae [Pea 7 ' Aon gh oS eon gee ge pa ae ee DEE ES Se faa perso Bhai Te 4 Bee ee ia oe ac” ? Ay se g 2 Fi ay SON of PaBs SS Vemety by SCA. EOP SR rin Gj Fiane Lrevs ree = ° pe ets RY HAY SN Bes i cooditee ae bra ee Dee en Tehayfinde fF moe \ a S| Ie ae —— pe ee! fio 4 Ney eee Bre Gop es = viet! een, eh Se int r eee ee tous Sa BU! 2uels Aerie) og Cera eonirs cs 7 5 ae quteee Chrsffon x a ofan iS | Burlay: TPL ye) Gres SOF ZC ethics Pree Oe re eos Mcrae Poe olf Gone Beto S\N Si ghuce = ty Se Peal Hae, lA eerste | He nee og eS SOE Ba Pondersck tone Ne eee f ee Bu F pe ale a eee fle gee | ‘cle ey ek eS SS pe See OS oe ae hpi! a cig eae atl me iz Sk on Ree anes TE an WE aatirs See he aga k tae Pipi ty, taal oe 2 Ene Pe a igs a Fe ae esis = oes PMA Beecz Poeund Stes atc F Sena Aa ae Be noe as eimeee. GE 2 = B ‘he piste Graal Takis aac oe ee ee. eee Corliea ifn Cpt gece Eee a BENS ai Pheer aal a tee SP rcriage Rye vilgtis * tamryd 8 San ser us, wore ew ca ae A dp eee ee Spee) da ae Ee ee Seas ot SS ge eee et Der C | pei Teme Vp neo getaeS e eee ec fen meee aa Peas iA is ae I Js em Ey NE. Soe Pac 2 er Gage ae 3 ge ee tG cal e463 seen PEG es CEN Pe ear Ct TN 20 1 TP crelinds \ Biiee Ho a fee ret Levey ®, \ Ss we Se Minorex 5 Soap: so eel <q oe “ge * Bs cerns ee Ea PS oe \ fe) Carenlt Res LA Coe 8 = N, a0 | J pipe iter Ge RS eS I ai oe = bap aemeeee 8 =e ee el oes cEUe fae Saige’ + T° Ly, a stim ASD cog smh ttre Eo oe ae Be | etn pe SS yD, wee ores h atl Aaa Wd ets ee ee. Aeros Bia Beg he y S ASE a Bo rte BY ee ce Ey | Res os Stee Spe chentsie®? “Hie. Somtans yeilacn wetted oo inte t H ee eg ee, AE See See a, S Sie fy 7 | Sree ca poet 28S 2 =e Y | % Rene 7 SS eet Ss Lda eels B . aif ee ifr urea sree cr 9 : oe = Ge te eres #s _yet Wo eds + PERG, Oe > Se ~ E Py: So cat ee A Gt A Tiga H = | cient G, Nei 7 etek Sl Sq, he fig, MaRS geet SS a ee Besant erie ee See Fe 40 toto If v5 asi eC pany Water Bees 3 uf Efe ee . a ee 8 a Sipitine. Cares ax eote © Tinie Hg ake a PN eau, ABP 5 B jie a ae ies i see ss a il een en sea So et ee 22) LC guecot cere Acdsee = 2 ae Aces ier tis oe eee a grit 3 aa S Severs sepa ad Pes = O7e - Ge shasta AICS epee e Nets \ tte A Hic Sy Ss —— ite pote. ee eee ee : Ee oO" a ire | 0, %, ieee (ees eC ee ETE | time somgith, Cae Hy SH —~, eer BE nea Se OES bench a PAE SAE | oN FAs A en fel a ie oes Woe La sd Cirh he een =, ¥ My ioe a, | oareeene eed Cee! Bh aes wale <q fn Paha oe en: ew oc aramaaia ey -u) Peak \ SE Mendis ES Bi ls ca ie a ac Tlaticy ae Bs nae Ae Lease oa Ec RENE EEN tye Bis es ol Seas S| ee otlsbrec ted Palle pa ety Mecca = PREY” Spm e -Spartivent a ea 4 eae ke Cae /. sea tele ham Lae™ yee ee 2 agers | he ae at 7p S E o owe of =) “st Wssar ie Se 8 jects o = », a he Bee ‘e u EE POEM cre ee OT? 4 omg ee "eile aes le Og Biles or ee ae, CS | ath sey el SN os 2 Free N age TC Ie : on es Se a a Pe Gee a are Pre 2 ‘ H Ss ae EarcFvals | os aa do = TE = fim ilare di 5 Se See SE aa Po Pz = oe CMF Lay B Barr : E Rs we Rah. Stile, | LzemyGres ys Afra oe = R ees ye Alm Ape ee peace As poe SN FF oe, apes a ape pwr ial oy \ lorry E - = F STM te DNs wee me =a ._ pe BEF viernes eS ees a> SFE E a See ae 5 i gf %,, Rae) CEE ED Bel a a AX rp ‘ yo Potter | eae anh ee Al ose sei fe Pe F cep, Ea ee SS fia Sl] cconiegeeeae ep tay: ee ME PENA be aN EE gil” Am Bee gs i Pamelcabars Eee eee Eyles Ret ao gee oe Se A pees Set A eee SS Aion VF # I Fi cee Wo x a, ESSA Ly eae ay R Py he ee Se OO a & Fe pa = G2 ae wad eae oe = hee i ee Ep, Excius Maze faded Pri \S koa (eames cae 3 23 | tomy A flonan Sy SOE, Je Sel lvagh Sl ease OA ed’, of eee ive Pie rz rear of Ss, Bas ge as FS, ere esT. Se Re 2 aa g aa) sgh Ale ek Sa Sta eel AC ae) |e mee a ee Oe eee ee ee EE Gee her | cae ie J Fa | Seta A Ee mec te (Se SR Sr \ 2 Sige" net ae ioe M peti He A Vet crae ee — oe eS Nene Ssh = ‘ See Ap Ce RES eae al. UA E 2 4 Pr ces 2 area Bec. oe = = Fa oH : aS av. ay asShy aun? eaGaleoNe AN RA Pe . DES yy, ER [Diez xa FA ‘ , a) eee Sisagh : oe he SEH Sst tae Soe aE in eh oa “a a = = Age Ses Ue i iraieakas ea Z fal pe ee TE ain. Sasa Cr fies DY ead VE ERC (Steere D I = u M a By eee Se Be 1s S| are orn 8, ie eee SEQ RSRK Ste, SRS oe gcc thy paetnel aan (re tal 3 Se Tee eS z a Pe a Eeentan | ie Lik Nha, LOA ges pe teers es ACS) SB hc ae wx CO £ FOL, Se =e WS Sie! didn ocxiosee tones erdhae E S ba) BL Ae aap tie ns eae R A AX % orig fri Pig Bini EARS Seca | er Le econ é Sa ES sabe. ee Bikes Ro nao wipe ee Ree see eae ae Nee tine GE ape NE pees, Se pte gS ed SEE REE tense Oo BR gS SNe ie eb fe Tae SEs: alechet st ge Deleon ff Sh a li eS eda ie BP Paaetllnn Pai. Sie ee vee (ee eee See = hg dieone wh nog — reece eS priest | ray SE eae Eede : Soule y a Fe ssa ba tae ! = oS 29] ee a = aie we aes oe Se Pear a ae iS Na 4 | yf OES SL ae a aledethe DES Age S 25 7 ——— SEE pis Blomice gf eee §c0 omic FIP OO Sve Se rai ei tihe BL YY YY PAS es SB RA RAB LA Sie Llabis a 39 a = ee ee ase oe A rn die tes Bere wef (eres ow. 5 ees ena ae PER inte aera A i = = 2 ae ee MR yey PTA RR Se SP Elcyrrus 4h ePE TERE A x: NRE As eI = ar ieee S$ Neve Se see ES oie sac A Aled: t 5 = = — vein Ne peer — tri SS Fethe \ ae x ‘& = ro E ine — R, Ni