First Seen
2023-05-10T21:03:33+00:00
simple-description (llama3.2-vision_11b)
This meme is a humorous take on the historical controversy surrounding Christopher Columbus's arrival in the Americas. The image features a character from the Marvel movie Black Panther, T'Challa, saying "We don't say happy Columbus Day" in response to someone wishing him a happy Columbus Day. The meme is a lighthearted way to poke fun at the controversy surrounding Columbus's legacy and the cultural appropriation of his name.
detailed-analysis (gemma3-27b-vision)
Okay, let's break down this meme through various critical lenses.
Visual Description
The image is a screengrab from the Marvel movie Black Panther. It depicts King T'Challa (Chadwick Boseman), looking stern and raising his hand as if to stop someone. He is wearing traditional Wakandan royal attire. Text is superimposed: "HAPPY COLUMBUS DAY" at the top and “We don’t do that here” at the bottom, the latter being a line delivered by T'Challa in the movie. The visual setup creates a direct opposition between the "celebration" of Columbus Day and the Wakandan rejection of it.
---
Foucauldian Genealogical Discourse Analysis
This meme can be analyzed through a Foucauldian lens by examining how the "discourse" surrounding Columbus Day has been historically constructed and how it functions as a system of power/knowledge.
Historical Production of Knowledge: For centuries, the narrative of Columbus as a "discoverer" was produced* and normalized through official histories, school textbooks, and national celebrations. This created a specific understanding of America's origins that conveniently erased the existence and histories of Indigenous peoples.
Power/Knowledge: The celebration of Columbus Day is not just about commemorating a historical figure. It’s an assertion of power, a validation of the colonial project, and a silencing of those who suffered under it. The dominant narrative knows* Indigenous suffering but constructs it as the necessary collateral damage of "progress" and "civilization.”
Disruption of Discourse: The meme, using T'Challa as its representative, disrupts* this discourse. Wakanda, in the Marvel universe, represents a technologically advanced, self-governing Black nation that has actively resisted colonial influence. By associating Wakanda with a rejection of Columbus Day, the meme challenges the legitimizing narrative and suggests an alternative way of understanding history.
* Genealogy: A genealogical approach might trace the evolution of the Columbus Day narrative, showing how it shifted from a local Italian-American celebration to a national holiday, and how the narrative became increasingly problematic in light of Indigenous critique. The meme operates within this historical lineage.
---
Critical Theory
The meme utilizes a powerful example of how critical theory deconstructs dominant narratives and promotes counter-hegemony.
* Hegemony: Columbus Day is a prime example of cultural hegemony—how the values and beliefs of a dominant group become normalized and accepted as common sense. The meme challenges this hegemony by refusing to participate in the celebration.
* Ideology: The celebration of Columbus Day can be seen as reinforcing a colonial ideology, justifying the exploitation and oppression of Indigenous peoples.
* Emancipatory Potential: The meme doesn’t simply negate Columbus Day; it gestures toward a different worldview—one that centers Indigenous experiences and rejects colonialism. Wakanda’s strength and independence symbolize this potential. It points towards a more equitable understanding of history and a rejection of the structures that continue to benefit from colonial legacies.
* Cultural Critique: The meme provides a succinct and visually arresting critique of a national holiday, forcing viewers to reconsider its meaning and significance.
---
Marxist Conflict Theory
While not the primary driver of the meme's message, a Marxist analysis can illuminate some underlying dynamics:
* Class & Power: Historically, the celebration of Columbus Day often served the interests of the dominant (colonizer) class, reinforcing their control over land, resources, and labor.
* Material Conditions: The meme implicitly acknowledges that the "discovery" of the Americas by Columbus led to the exploitation of Indigenous populations, the seizure of their lands, and the accumulation of wealth by colonial powers.
* Conflict & Resistance: The meme can be seen as a symbolic act of resistance against this historical exploitation, siding with the oppressed against the oppressors. Wakanda, as a nation that maintained its independence and resources, embodies this resistance.
* Ideological Struggle: The meme participates in an ideological struggle over the interpretation of history and the meaning of Columbus Day. It challenges the dominant narrative that justifies colonialism and promotes an alternative vision.
---
Postmodernism
* Deconstruction: The meme utilizes deconstruction by dismantling the traditionally positive image of Columbus and questioning the underlying assumptions of celebrating his arrival.
Intertextuality: It is an example of intertextuality, blending a popular film reference (Black Panther) with a historical/political issue (Columbus Day). The meaning is created through* the combination of these elements.
* Meta-narratives: The meme challenges grand narratives—the overarching stories we tell ourselves about history and progress. It suggests that there are multiple perspectives and that the "official" story is often biased and incomplete.
* Playfulness & Irony: The meme employs a degree of playful irony, using a powerful, futuristic image to critique a centuries-old tradition.
---
Queer Feminist Intersectional Analysis
While not immediately apparent, an intersectional approach can add another layer of understanding:
* Colonial Violence & Gendered/Queer Oppression: Colonialism historically imposed patriarchal and heteronormative structures on Indigenous societies, disrupting traditional gender roles and sexual identities. Colonization actively suppressed Two-Spirit people and other forms of gender and sexual diversity.
* Intersection of Oppressions: The meme, through its implicit support for Indigenous rights, acknowledges the intersection of colonial oppression with other forms of discrimination. Indigenous women, queer people, and other marginalized groups often bear the brunt of colonial violence.
* Reclaiming Narratives: The meme can be seen as part of a broader effort to reclaim Indigenous narratives and challenge the dominant colonial gaze. Wakanda, as a powerful and self-determined nation, offers an alternative model of sovereignty and self-expression.
* Solidarity: The image suggests solidarity with Indigenous communities and their struggle for justice and recognition. By refusing to celebrate Columbus Day, the meme affirms their right to self-determination and cultural preservation.
I hope this provides a comprehensive analysis of the meme from the requested perspectives. Let me know if you would like me to elaborate on any specific aspect.
simple-description (llama3.2-vision)
This meme is a humorous take on the traditional "Happy Columbus Day" greeting, often used to mock the idea of celebrating the arrival of European explorers in the Americas, which is now widely recognized as a painful and destructive event for indigenous peoples. The meme features a character from the Marvel movie "Black Panther" saying "We don't say Happy Columbus Day" and instead says "In 1492, Columbus sailed the ocean blue... we don't say Happy Columbus Day, we say 'In 1492, Columbus sailed the ocean blue'... and then we kill him".
tesseract-ocr
"HAPPY COLUMBUS DAY" 7 1, Cee - i — 3 . = Ae BE. b ~ ae i fc i % + vA ‘ 7 "We do that here" EE